You are not your body, you are not your mind, you are not your thoughts.
You are not them, because you can't control them. If you were in control, you wouldn't have pain or anxiety or craving, because you would simply choose to not have pain or anxiety or craving. No sane man would choose to have pain or anxiety or craving. Yet you have pain and anxiety and craving, because you are not in control of them, because they are not You.
Cravings, anger, thoughts - they come up, they exist. Just like a dream exists while sleeping. But, they are not You, just like a dream is not you.
The true You, is only awareness of being. It is a calm, ever present place beyond all physical sensations. It can be accessed at any moment. For most of us, this takes practice in the form of meditation, as our ego resists.
About craving and your book, it works because shows you a separation of craving and you. Allowing you to be aware of craving without having to act upon it. Because you learn it is not the true You.
This idea can be of help, besides the regular therapy or book, to free yourself of suffering.
If you would like to know more, I can recommend the teaching of the Buddha or Ramana Maharshi:
This is also what the Upanishads start with that you're not the body, nor mind nor thoughts, but the Atman. It branches differently from Buddhism and goes further connecting the Atman to the Brahman (universal reality). Both of these however start out the same and even realizing the start of that journey is a very big shift in how most of us live our daily lives.
It is very difficult to look or feel otherwise once you grasp this fundamental concept that a lot of spiritual texts teach.
I reject the premise that total control over X is a prerequisite for being X.
The above line of thinking leads itself ad absurdum resulting in "you" being nothing, not existing. We're supposed to accept this sleight of hand as deep wisdom? I prefer to interpret it as a hint at an error in the reasoning, personally. But you do you.
I agree with the general idea, having OCD it's a lesson that was important for me to learn to cope with the condition, but I don't think anxiety or pain is something that is just negative and to be avoided. They might not subjectively feel good, but they serve a function, for survival. A sane mind could very well still choose to feel anxiety, because it fuels actions that help us survive.
That seems backwards to me - fundamentally all that you are is emergent from your physical body, because literally what else is there? Yes to a degree you can ‘rise above’ your physical condition, but even ‘mind over matter’ is a bit of a misnomer when your mind is matter. Your awareness of the external world is sorely comprised of your physical senses, and even your inner world is largely a loop of ruminating on sensory input. What ‘you’ are is the experience of the present, and it’s not happening anywhere but your body.
> You are not them, because you can't control them.
I think this might be two different questions, asked from two different domains.
When you look at a human being from the outside, of course, everything there is is the physical body. In fact, you can do away with the idea of a “soul“ or “mind” entirely and simply study the behavior. This is what BF Skinner did. And it works amazingly well.
But when you ask from inside, looking at yourself as an automaton or an animal to be conditioned, might not be helpful. It might be more helpful to see the urges, desires, anxieties as responses, which are not you, but are merely happening to you, observed by you.
The two views sound very different. But at the same time, they might be just different perspectives onto the same thing.
> fundamentally all that you are is emergent from your physical body, because literally what else is there?
This is perfectly valid if you firmly reject the existence of, say, a soul. But the experience of people who have died and returned, or has NDEs, suggests that there is more than just a physical body.
> What ‘you’ are is the experience of the present, and it’s not happening anywhere but your body.
People who've had out of body experiences would beg to differ. You can say that they are all imagining things - and it is plausible - but quite unlikely that people from different continents all experience very similar things.
> This is perfectly valid if you firmly reject the existence of, say, a soul. But the experience of people who have died and returned, or has NDEs, suggests that there is more than just a physical body.
I don't think those experiences require something other than the body necessarily. It's possible that everything that makes you "you" could be your brain state stored as neuron connections and neurochemistry. Then it's possible that if you're dead for a short period of time such brain state is preserved.
Right, except this true self isn't truly accessible all the time, is it?
I don't think it's the case for everyone at least, because the "fake self" is made of things that have roots in your history as a person, and most people need to rely on these until they learn better. And for many people (most?), I believe this is a lifetime journey.
Also, I don't believe it's possible to free yourself from suffering, to me it makes more sense to accept and sublimate rather than eliminate it.
True, for most people, including myself, we are on a journey without end. Our conditioning is strong, so be it.
The journey of enlightenment is like a compass: it points you to the direction of the North, yet you will never arrive at the final place called North, because this place does not exist. Despite this, a compass is still of use.
My understanding is that the core is 3 A's: awareness, acceptance and appreciation.
I do control (at least) my body and my thoughts and I am a triune being of body, mind and spirit.
Body being the physical actuator, mind being the conscious thoughts and spirit, being an integral part of my true self, what outlasts even amnesia.
I don't become another being if my body changed and I lost my memory. It'd still be the same me but I'd start adopting and forming a new identity and personality - or shape back into the preexisting one if the memories started came back.
In contrast, what I understood from your post, if my true me was only my "awareness of myself," I'd completely lose myself in a temporary state of amnesia without possibly of finding it back - unless someone else, in my concept that'd be a godly creature in the spiritual realm, was able to hold on to some state of my mind for me and hand it back (assigning the void *pointer back to my body instance) - but I'm not sure how that transfers to Buddhism.
Can you NOT think of a pink elephant? Can you choose your next thought or the thought after that? I know you can cultivate an intention to think about a certain topic or and that when you do think the thoughts they feel "yours" and like they are being "generated" by you. But to go from that to a claim of "control" over thoughts there is a huge gap.
See also Peter Ralston: Ending Unnecessary Suffering: How to Create a Powerful, Complete, and Peaceful Life
He's got some podcasts out which are worth trying.
This is largely in line with Tim Galwey's "Inner Game" books [0] specifically and Zen in general.
After reading many of Gallwey's books and also Zen and the Art of Archery [1], I would summarize it all down into one sentence:
Western coaching focuses on telling your body what to do, Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.
e.g. this story from the Inner Game of Skiing [2] summarizes it well:
"I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them:
- observe the angle of your skis to the ground
- flat on the ground is 1
- as far over as you can tilt is 10
- just feel what angle you are at as your are moving down the hill.
A young lady then came up to ask me 'So what is the correct angle??'. I told her 'There is no correct angle, just observe what angle your skis are.' "
If you prefer a video example, this youtube video of Gallwey teaching people hit play tennis for the first time is great [3] (note: it's very low video quality but excellent at showing his techniques).
I’m realizing much of good advice comes down to simply paying attention to whatever you want to improve. The progression is an artifact of that attention.
I have always been able to maintain a tiny coach in my brain while coding. Might have come from cycling. I saw similar notions when studying meditation. It’s also reflected in some martial arts, and in Slow is Smooth, Smooth is Fast.
Unfortunately there are other aspects of my life where the little coach never showed his stupid face.
How is my pace and how is my form? You’ve been working on this for five minutes and it should have taken 30 seconds. Why? That thing you did earlier today resulted in a red build. Why? Is this a me problem, and I need to shift how I work, or is this an us problem and we need a tool or a code/process change to stop it?
Lack of introspection tends to result in a lack of grace for coworkers, and I find it tends to hamper process and runbook improvements, because these people insist that only idiots make those sorts of mistakes, while working overtime to paper over their own. They have in effect begun to believe their own public relations material. The emperor has no clothes.
As one example, I often find that while developing I will make a mistake but catch it before committing, or at least before the PR. I count this toward my priority estimator for tech debt/DX effort. When junior developers or infrequent visitors to that same part of the code don’t catch the same error before someone else witnesses it, I now have empirical proof that this piece of code is a footgun. And by then I’ve already been making plans A and B for what to do about it, while waiting for builds, meetings, walking to lunch…
If your lead is almost making a mistake, that’s cause for concern. If others are making it, then that concern is founded.
> Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.
Isn't this basically how learning works for most physical things? Riding a bike, swimming, etc..
I just came back from a bunch of icy hiking in Salt Lake City (KubeCon was last week). I wanted to climb a bunch of mountains but I had no gear except rubber sole hiking sneakers. Almost every place I went had slippery ice and steep inclines, but it was all no problem. That would be Bell Canyon upper falls, Heugh's Canyon, Neff's Canyon to the meadow, Grandeur Peak from Church Fork, Lake Blanche, Donut Falls and Frary Peak. Some of these were done in the rain or after snow.
You very quickly get used to what type of traction you get on certain types of surfaces and then you make small adjustments to improve stability. It's all trial and error and very dynamic. Maybe at the start you grab bushes for extra precaution, or you go super slow, or you crab walk down just to get a feel for how your footwear interacts with the ground.
How you shift your weight along with how much of your sneaker has contact on the ground play a big factor but it's not something you can easily explain, you just need to do it and see how it goes.
The dangerous part is walking downhill. When you test the friction for the next step you're taking, you shift your center of balance too much forward and compromise the traction of the other leg. And sometimes it's not even the shoe losing traction, but the ground you stepped on slides under pressure. That's why it's good to have better traction options available when you already start sliding somewhere.
I found after a while, the tests were done visually. Looking for the spots with the most grooves or little pieces of terrain to anchor the front of your foot on. If something didn't pop out immediately, I took it slower and evaluated the surrounding area to assess the risk in case I slipped. It was like going through a flow chart in real-time.
I slipped twice after ~260,000 steps where 80% of those steps were going uphill or downhill on mountains with a lot of mixed terrain (mud, running water, stepping on rocks over a creek, icy inclines, etc.).
Keep in mind, the two slips were I actually fell on my butt. I had a bunch of wobbly moments where it was possible to recover without falling. Basically the "learning" for me was trusting my body to be comfortable with a bunch of micro-slips where you can feel the ground shift below you, but by the time you take your next step, it recovers.
If you’re standing still but still moving, you have failed the minimum required friction.
The thing with ice is that you often hurt yourself by stubbornly trying not to fall down, making it uncontrolled when you do. Watching glacier mountaineers is quite informative of how often my instincts are counterproductive.
Sure, check out the Myth of Zen and the Art of Archery:
Eugen Herrigel’s “Zen in the Art of Archery” has been widely read as a
study of Japanese culture. By reconsidering and reorganizing Herrigel’s
text and related materials, however, this paper clari³es the mythical
nature of “Zen in the Art of Archery” and the process by which this myth
has been generated. This paper ³rst gives a brief history of Japanese
archery and places the period at which Herrigel studied Japanese archery
within that time frame. Next, it summarizes the life of Herrigel’s teacher,
Awa Kenzõ. At the time Herrigel began learning the skill, Awa was just
beginning to formulate his own unique ideas based on personal spiritual
experiences. Awa himself had no experience in Zen nor did he uncondi-
tionally approve of Zen. By contrast, Herrigel came to Japan in search of
Zen and chose Japanese archery as a method through which to approach
it. The paper goes on to critically analyze two important spiritual episodes
in “Zen and the Art of Archery.” What becomes clear through this analysis
is the serious language barrier existing between Awa and Herrigel. The tes-
timony of the interpreter, as well as other evidence, supports the fact that the
complex spiritual episodes related in the book occurred either when there
was no interpreter present, or were misinterpreted by Herrigel via the inter-
preter’s intentionally liberal translations. Added to this phenomenon of
misunderstanding, whether only coincidental or born out of mistaken inter-
pretation, was the personal desire of Herrigel to pursue things Zen. Out of
the above circumstances was born the myth of “Zen in the Art of Archery.”
I read The Art of Setting Stones shortly after Zen and the Art of Archery. If you’re into landscaping at all, I think it’s a good bookend for the other.
Thanks, I read The Inner Game of Tennis when I was young - and watching [3] just now reminded once again me of the core ideas. Letting go, (re)discovering the joy of letting your body do the right thing, these are all things I've suppressed for too long with "programmer's mind". Sometimes the hyper-analytical thing that works so well for us is the very thing that blocks us.
Paying attention to what your body is doing is a good way to screw up anything you're trying to do. Paying attention to your thoughts is the same, it turns you inward and you become awkward and weird. This stuff is nonsense.
Sounds like the typical trap: you first need to separate the inner judge from the inner observer. Otherwise you just take your bully for a tour.
It is hard practice for those with adverse childhood experiences and the resulting internalized criticism to eventually be able to be aware of something without the negative stream of judgment and the subconscious desire to change and control it.
You either learn to tame the judge, or you have it act out on your environment, or more directly towards yourself. Your choice.
Book recommendation: Sarah Peyton, Self-Resonance.
“Therefore introspection and awareness are entirely different. Introspection leads to frustration, to further conflict, for in it is implied the desire for change and change is merely a modified continuity. […]
I think there’s a point to be made here but there’s also a difference between practice and performance.
During practice, awareness is super important. During performance, it’s more about intuition and muscle memory developed from that practice.
At least for me, this is based on years of being a touring drummer in a band. I imagine athletes are the same.
I wouldn’t call it nonsense though. Everybody’s different and every activity requires different things of you.
I became familiar with The Inner Game of Tennis via a presentation by Alan Kay, who now seems like a distant echo from a bygone age, when computing technology was really intended as a tool to aid and augment human capability, rather than the jester in Thus Spoke Zarathustra as it dances and sparkles over and past us. In the presentation, Kay provides a short clip of that exact news story featuring Gallwey working with Molly, and notes that after the first few times saying "hit", Molly's arm begins to move despite her not yet intending to actually hit the ball!
I've noticed a similar phenomenon in martial arts. When I focused less on making my body do the correct technique, and instead imagined wireframe fighters similar to the ones in Smash Bros. games attacking me, and the technique I was performing was a countermove—I found that thinking about the imaginary opponent rather than my own body made my technique more correct, as my peers and instructors had noticed.
> I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them: observe the angle of your skis to the ground
Oh interesting. This is very similar to how I was taught technical 4x4 driving: rather than obsessing over where the car or the trail is, simply pay attention to where each tire is and how it’s interacting with the terrain.
On difficult river crossings and boulder-strewn trails, developing that awareness made a world of difference. Once I could intuitively track all four tires, navigating obstacles became almost automatic. It felt like 95% of the skill.
I read Allan Carr's The Easy Way To Stop Smoking in 1999. I read it in one sitting while smoking a pack of cigarettes, and when I finished the book I never smoked again.
It has been 27 years, so I don't remember the details of the book and may be getting it wrong, but my takeaway was that the book circumvented all of the excuses your brain comes up with to start smoking again. It's like a nicotine craving sends a message to your brain, which comes up with an excuse to allow you to smoke again. For example, about four hours into "quitting smoking", your brain starts coming up with stuff like: "I'll just cut down to 6 a day", or "Maybe today isn't the best day to quit", or "I'll just smoke on weekends", or "I'll start smoking menthols", or "I'll just have one now and see if I can make it through the rest of the day", and then you're right back where you started. The book had an answer for all of these off-ramps, and made it clear that they were all created by nicotine cravings.
Hmm, I wouldn't really say that's the takeaway of "Easy way to quit smoking" that really resonates with smokers. In fact, i'd say it's the opposite message the book lays out.
This article is suggesting you have to "battle" your cravings, to stop smoking.
The books message is the opposite. It's seeing that you gain nothing from cigarettes, that they have created the solution to a problem they themselves created. It's seeing that there is nothing to "give up". There is no battling your cravings.
In fact, you have already lost if you are battling your cravings, because you are giving power to that thing. You are affirming that you are having to "give up" something by battling through the cravings, surely there must be some value in that thing because it's so hard to give it up.
I agree you shouldn't focus on your cravings, you should forget about them, by focusing on something else. Then the cravings gradually diminish. But "observing the craving" can also mean you are craving less, because you are experiencing more the process of observing, rather than experiencing the craving so badly. It's a tricck of the mind I believe.
The point is to understand that mechanism: You crave bad things not because of what you get from them in the end, but because of the excitement you feel when you are "reaching out" for them. It feels like something very valuable, is within your reach, and that gives you a great sense of excitement, which we enjoy. We want to stay in such a state, because moving away from it would make us feel we are giving up something very valuable.
I guess that is why people get addicted to gambling.
I underwent an operation in hospital and they wouldn't let me drink anything for a long time before the operation. I wanted to drink so badly that I came up with a plan in my head: Once I get out of this hospital I will refrain from drinking a whole day, just to be able to experience how good it feels when you then are actually able to drink.
Of course no such thing happened once I got out of the hospital, because I no longer had that enormous desire to drink anything. So I didn't feel the need to make myself thirsty just to be able to quench my thirst.
> But "observing the craving" can also mean you are craving less, because you are experiencing more the process of observing, rather than experiencing the craving so badly. It's a tricck of the mind I believe.
Yeah, I 100% agree with this. It's the basis for https://urgesurfing.org/ (just an mp3 file with someone talking through the act of 'surfing' an urge) which is a nice tool I've used before for getting used to the act of disassociating the craving from yourself in a way.
and a core part of the book is also some kind of brainwashing. The message that smoking is bad and therefore nothing to be given up is more or less repeated over and over probably a 100 times.
I think the missing part is the something you do instead.
I didn't stop chewing my fingernails. I started clipping them.
There's an industry of organizations that run "porn addiction" recovery programs. I think it's irrelevant whether or not you believe watching porn is a good it bad thing to do. The question that these organizations never answer is, "What should you do instead?" The implication is that people who want to stop watching porn should become asexual. Not only is that ridiculous, it demonizes the person's sexuality - a core part of their self - which gives an extreme amount of power and salience to the subject of avoidance; and pits them in a duel against their own self.
While I agree with most of the article, I gotta add that Allen Carr’s method is not fool-proof.
The first read through is magical in its obviousness and simplicity. It works for a lot of people, which will praise it as if magic. But if by any chance you fall into the trap of smoking again, the book will have lost 90% of its power, simply because you have seen your cravings overcome its message once.
It’s taken me 10 more years after first reading the book, using the conventional techniques of nicotine substitutes, to finally quit for good.
Every moment of your life, you are training as hard as any professional athlete. Training for what? To be exactly the person that you have become so far.
Quitting sugar is a funny example, because for many people, some of those craving feelings might be coming from the gut microbiome demanding more of what it wants. I had to cut out most sugars/simple carbs for gut health reasons and what do you know, the cravings vanished simultaneously with the other unpleasant symptoms.
Not saying that's the only driver for sugar cravings of course, the brain and gut are in dialogue.
In other words, you're saying the sugar craving monster might be literal - there's literally a thing inside you that feeds on sugar and dies a little when you don't eat it, and that's why it's funny.
This is probably safe for your microbiome, which can do with less sugar eating bacteria if you don't eat much sugar.
I read that apparently bacteria that is feeding on fiber will attack the colon and stomach(?) if they don’t get enough fiber.
So what I am asking myself is:
1. is this also the case with sugar?
2. if it is the case with sugar, does it lead to people getting miserable while trying to cut down on sugar what leads to more incentive to remove the feeling with a little hit of sugar -> leading to a kind of negative cycle?
It is indeed not willpower that steers the body most. The more the reasoning brain imposes will on the body, the more the body/unconscious protests by causing pain.
The art is instead to assure the body that all is fine, for example calming it by rithmic movements like walking or boxed breathing. After a while the body admits there's nothing it needs to fight for, the pain and cravings deminish.
It occurs to me that if craving can be addressed one-battle-at-a-time, the opposite may be true: procrastination (or resistance to positive change) can be addressed one tiny bite at a time? I’m not sure what that looks like but it seems like an inversion of the same idea? I’d like to know more about this.
“Habits” was the first answer for me. Habits obviate the need to spend willpower on mundane things, so I get more of it to spend elsewhere. Second effect is that having accomplished several things first thing in the morning rewards me with dopamine, which creates a credible promise of more dopamine for other things. Procrastination is lack of belief in the future dopamine fix.
Start with habits. “Atomic habits” is a good starting point.
This is a common procrastination technique, yes! Doing even just 10 minutes of work a day is a method people use, because it's just 10 minutes, it's next to impossible to say 10 minutes is too much work. And then you work up from there.
Yep - efficiency maxing is a curse that few recognise. I know I fail to recognise The benefits of taking a walking with no headphones, just relaxing to recharge, and sleep.
You should look into Tiny Habits from BJ Fogg, the head of Stanford's "Behavior Design Lab." This is precisely the idea and it really does work wonders. A few well-selected habits can totally transform one's life.
"you want to smoke because the craving feels bad, not because you actually want the cigarette."
This is an interesting assumption I often think about. The cigarette makes you feel different, or even better. Alcohol can do the same, it brings your mind in another state.
I'm not saying you should smoke or drink away your stress and anxieties but using a substance can be a positive experience, just like taking a run or have a fun night at a comedy club.
Should one only strive for positive experiences from natural effects, and if so, can I play GTA6 to feel better?
I think you're describing the difference between being addicted or not. For many addicts, most of the time that they choose to smoke or drink (or gamble, or shoot up, etc) it's because they want to assuage the discomfort of a craving.
They probably started on this path because of the good feelings associated with the drug, and they still enjoy those too, but they continue to do the drug even once the bad consequences outweigh the fun because of avoiding negative feelings.
Plenty of people drink or smoke only occasionally and choose to do so because of the positive effects, and those people aren't really the target of "The easy way to stop X" books.
Alcohol and tobacco are a bit complicated in how they act so let's pick a better drug for this example, amphetamines.
In simple terms, both GTA 6 (and food, sex, music, a "like" on a post) and taking amphetamines release dopamine. But playing a game doubles your dopamine vs the baseline, while amphetamines release 10x or more.
10x is too much dopamine and your brain will turn down its reward signaling so you may end up with tolerance, crashes, addiction. Also it's hard to fall asleep, which has its own cascade of problems.
But those specific substances can also produce cravings that are deeply unpleasant. Coffee also makes me feel good, but the worst withdrawal I might get is a headache that an Advil resolves.
This reminds me a lot of DNRS and Primal Trust, tools that are supposed to help with the mental shift in healing from Long Covid and other chronic illnesses.
There is a mental phenomenon, like tension, or craving, or distraction. It may not be obvious. The obvious name might be "back pain", or "cigarettes", or "stress". You first learn to notice and name a truer, primary cause. This is why it can work so fast. Sometimes, all you need to learn is that there is a truer primary cause for it to become obvious.
2. Shifting focus to an incompatible mental state.
The knowledge that pain is caused by tension is incompatible with a focus on injury. The mental representation of one negates the other. The focus on a neutral process of craving negates the belief about physical need. The knowledge of the process of distraction inhibits the focus on stressful distractors.
In the brain you're finding activations which inhibit the firing of undesirable neural activity. The exact mental state will vary by individual, which is why particular visualizations work so well for some and not others.
3. Practice
Through repeated practice of associating stimuli/experience with the truer more desirable mental state you learn the habit of going straight from the stimulus to the good state, bypassing the undesirable state. You inhibit the brains old prediction of the next link in the chain and replace it with a prediction of a better one.
Now the above works very well when there is a truer root cause than the one you've noticed in the past, but the crazy thing is that it works even if you can only convince yourself its a truer root cause. Even if your body really is damaged and is reporting as much with pain you can use the above (or similar meditation techniques) to master/overcome/ignore that pain, though it is harder and requires much more of the practice step.
There's horrible animalistic inner conflict in me? I don't think so. If there's a wolf in me it's because I ate it. But let's put it like this: you can want things in a simple, emotive, dumb, heartfelt way, while simultaneously wanting conflicting things in a cognitive, reasoned, sophisticated, unpersuasive way. What to do?
My insight is: dumb drives care about what's easy and comfortable, therefore they have no input in sophisticated moral reasoning, and can't disagree with it. Their only message is that you function badly when uncomfortable. Therefore by consciously clearing the path to make the morally preferred things easy you can avoid inner conflict.
Wow, this is so interesting. My girlfriend and I just finished reading Allen Carr, which has helped a lot with anxiety. And the reason why I picked it up was because I thought anxiety might be amplifying or even causing physical pain. The fact that other people were able to overcome pain through mental motions gives me a lot of hope. Thanks for linking this.
If I'm interested in reading more about this without picking up books specific to smoking, tennis, and spiritually, is "The Experience Machine" by Andy Clark in the same vein?
Made me think of this anecdote from Harry Browne's book How I Found Freedom in an Unfree World:
> One night I had to give a lecture and she announced that she was going out with someone else. I was sure they’d wind up in bed — and it infuriated me. I didn’t want to stop her but I still felt terribly jealous.
On the way to the lecture, I stopped for dinner. For the previous three hours, I’d been unable to think of anything but the terrible thing I was sure was going to happen. I finally decided that I wouldn’t be able to give the lecture unless I calmed down.
> After ordering my dinner, I started to use the technique. I had never seen the other man involved — which always seems to make such a person more formidable. So I pictured him as the exact opposite of me, the kind of man I wouldn’t like, the kind of man who could sweet-talk women away from their lovers. I imagined them doing together every obscene thing I could think of. 21
I was determined to keep thinking about the scene over and over again until it no longer bothered me emotionally. However, I suddenly realized that I was thinking about the lecture I was going to give; I hadn’t made it all the way through the imaginary sex scene even once. So I turned my mind back to the horrible scene and concentrated on it again.
> But it quickly became apparent that my mind had wandered once again. And then it dawned on me that the scene no longer held any terror for me — not even any interest, in fact.
> So I spent the rest of my dinner time planning my lecture and never gave the jealousy problem another thought. In all, it had taken only about five minutes of attention to eliminate all the pain and fear.
It all sounds great but physical cravings can be deeply ingrained in your neuronal structure and can take a long time to get rid of. I wonder to what extent this is one of those things where once you do this it feels like a massive breakthrough, but then 2 months later you're back to where you started as if nothing happened.
I really like what the author wrote and I'm one of those people who was freed from their chronic back pains by just reading the first 60 pages of jon Sarnos book.
There are certainly a lot of truth in cure your body by mind but there are significant dangers in going too far. As a runner too often I push through the mental wall, sometimes it leads to far worse injuries. Same as a founder, I pushed through many times and the end results were not worth the cost. Balance is the key that I am yet to discover.
Most nonfiction books present zero to a handful of novel core concepts that could be described in a few pages and then spend the rest filling pages with anecdotes, the history of the discovery etc. that, while often interesting and entertaining, are not strictly necessary to convey that message at all.
I would actually find it much more surprising if a reportedly life-changing method, which can be implemented purely by changes in behavior, would work only if presented in a hundreds of pages but not in a couple of paragraphs. (And, to be very honest, I would probably also not spend $10 on a couple of paragraphs. That's not how I've learned to model the economics of buying and reading books :)
Sometimes all it takes is one small tool in your toolbox to make a big change. As the song says, I am downright amazed at what I can destroy with just a hammer.
Maybe, but it's not completely implausible, either. If someone has written a review that contains exactly the right key point from the book, it's possible.
Consider how concisely some hard-won scientific achievements could be presented to somebody from an earlier period. "Many illnesses are caused by omnipresent microorganisms that can be killed by heat, alcohol, and soap" sent back through time alone could, if believed, save billions, completely experimentally and without any theory of cellular life, bacteria etc.
Why shouldn't the same hold for psychological techniques as well?
For me, what I think of as ”you“ is not a tiny homunculus in my head which steers the rest of me with commands and controls. “You“ are not in control, “you” is a crowd of competing impulses and memories, with a thin mask on it that lets you imagine yourself as the boss.
It seems like reading some of these ideas helps the reasoning brain discover the correct signal to send out to the unconscious mind to make something happen. And in a remarkably abstract way - the reasoning brain can receive a message like "it's all in your head" and (if conditions are right) discover the signal that suppresses certain back pain.
Great article I first heard about Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind through Steve Jobs. Just finished reading it and gained so much from it. Even though I struggle to meditate every single day, I truly believe sticking with it will pay off immensely.
Good article and worth internalizing before a crisis occurs.
Mind over matter is a futile battle. Your body and all of its autonomous systems can't be neglected. Learn to work together or suffer the consequences.
Over 20 years ago I quit smoking after being a pack and a half smoker since high school. I didn’t torture myself by trying to quit, by cutting down or using some aid like nicotine alternatives.
Instead, I simply ran through a simple mental exercise every time I started a cigarette. I imagined and felt the few things that I really didn’t like about smoking - the look and smell of an old full ashtray, the taste of a stale cigarette, the gagging feeling of a first daily cigarette one sometimes experiences, the feeling of smoke in my eyes etc. Every cigarette every time, and after that I would just carry on with my cigarette. I didn’t try to give up smoking.
After a few weeks I realized I was often stubbing out the cigarettes early, not through a conscience decision! A few weeks later I just … stopped wanting a cigarette, and haven’t wanted one since.
Today, for the first time I hear of Allen Carr’s technique. It’s not the same, but related and I’m amazed I never heard of it! Both it seems result in changing one’s core beliefs?
One note of warning: I think this technique could be really dangerous if applied to things like overeating etc.
Another important point I think is that I was in an environment conducive to stopping smoking - my wife hated it. If your in an environment where smoking is rewarded, like for example smoking with a buddy, or regular pub sessions, it surely would be less effective.
If anyone wants more info or advice on this, email me.
This is effectively Alan Carrs method in his famous book. I just listened to half of it on audiobook (on YouTube, no less) and quit smoking too, years ago.
> The same thing happens with John Sarno’s book, Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection.
This was me, flat on my back, pretty much paralyzed in bed from pain from moving in any direction. I bought the book on my tablet and started reading, got to the part about how I was doing it exactly wrong, and that getting up and moving is the way out. That was a starter's pistol for me. I hobbled my way out of back pain and that has been my first resort ever since.
I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.
Yes- but all has to be in moderation and as a combination of treatments. I get people telling me all the time to do wild things which ignore the slip disks will hurt in the days after, sure I can do it in the moment but I will pay for it.
>I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.
The woo woo with Sarno is in the physiological explanations that he gives for pain (ostensible oxygen deprivation which turns out to not be the case), but subconscious self sabotage is a fairly sound explanation for what's going on.
In Adlerian psychology this is usually framed as the teleogy rather than the etiology of pain, anxiety and so forth. Ask what is the purpose of pain or anxiety, not its cause. We often maintain pain or anxiety because its a safety mechanism. You don't stay home because you suffer from pain or are anxious, the pain or anxiety protects you from change.
Nice techniques. And you can also let go of steering altogether. Here's an apt fight club scene for the compulsive self optimizing, self improving control freaks out there.
I've been learning about reoccurring pain, lethargy or illness in the body and that these symptoms can occur in response to trauma (often repressed)- its a sign that emotions are stuck and need to be allowed/worked through.
There are MANY eastern things(not just philosophies) like patanjali yogasutras that is the framework for this, & is basically are cures for a great life, but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way
"but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way"
Hehe, that reminds me about the hype about chinese medicine. That was largely not understood in china at all, as to them it was old not working medicine and the modern medicine obviously better.
In other words I disagree that western audiences need a western presentation in general it can be the opposite, the mysticism of the ancient asian traditions are part of the package (never mind that most "ancient" traditions are in reality just decades old and just new interpretations of old teaching)
In fact the west is so lost to this propaganda that they even blind themselves to western esoteric info. Most of the west thinks santa is fake lmao! They don't understand the meaning of philosophy, mythology, story & theory & differences between them.
Yup, most of the eastern world is westernized since the invention of nation states & doesn't even know how to use eastern stuff. HN is at its lowest of information & intelligence in my past 20 years spent here.
This is such bullshit. Pain is a physical signal from your body telling you that a part of you is compromised.
I believe that you can train yourself to ignore pain, but that's literally a last resort. And my experience with this was that the pain just manifests in other ways, like anxiety.
Call me ancient but I think that the reverse is true, it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse
Yeah. I twisted my ankle badly about 2 years ago, for a middle aged guy anyway, and no amount of positive thoughts helped putting weight on the ankle for at least a month.
Chronic pain often is not a useful signal. Consider that there is little correlation between back pain and what MRI or whatever modern diagnostic can show. One person where the diagnostic shows that nothing is wrong may suffer daily. Another with spine discs that are obviously damaged may suffer very little.
The same is with damaged meniscus. One can run with no pain. Another suffers at each walking step. Sometimes an operation can help, but it is rather invasive with non-trivial risk of complications. And given that meniscus does not heal by itself if a person can learn not to feel the pain, it can greatly improve quality of life.
Pain is often a meaningful signal, but it can be psychosomatic as well in some cases. However, I do applaud your concluding observation that, basically, healing the body can heal the mind. Mind and body communicate in both directions and to heal or develop must work together.
>it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse
Mental issues are eliminated when one stops giving them much importance and pretty much ignores them. Its known since ancient times that mind can only add and multiply, there is no subtraction. In the east they say "mind is like a still lake's water, to calm down the ripples all you have to do is wait, any attempt to counter them will only cause more".
But the big problem here is ego, if we think our thoughts and emotions are very valuable, they "make us who we are" and other modern age bullshit, we will have hard time getting rid of them.
For physical issues you got to a doctor and they do what they can, that's about it.
It depends. Pain receptors aren't precise because we are messy bags of protein. They necessarily start doing their thing before actual damage has happened. In those scenarios you can judiciously ignore pain that will not cascade into lasting injury.
Often in life, your body is the one steering you. And sometimes, to get to do the thing you want, you can’t just convince yourself with reason or arguments, or will yourself, or do the exercises to get there - you need to learn the magic formula, the secret words, to trick the body into acting in a way that gets you the outcome you want.
Sometimes we need to find a way to steer the body, and the body only listens when you say the magic words. I like these examples, not only because they are all actually powerful and useful, but also because it feels like I am whispering the secrets of the universe - that through saying the magic words, I am being granted special root access to my own programming.
Modern humans reinventing the bicameral mind from first principles. This is a golden retriever's inner monologue seeing a treat being held out and hearing "sit"
I would like to take it one step further:
You are not your body.
This is the ultimate teaching of the Buddha.
You are not your body, you are not your mind, you are not your thoughts.
You are not them, because you can't control them. If you were in control, you wouldn't have pain or anxiety or craving, because you would simply choose to not have pain or anxiety or craving. No sane man would choose to have pain or anxiety or craving. Yet you have pain and anxiety and craving, because you are not in control of them, because they are not You.
Cravings, anger, thoughts - they come up, they exist. Just like a dream exists while sleeping. But, they are not You, just like a dream is not you.
The true You, is only awareness of being. It is a calm, ever present place beyond all physical sensations. It can be accessed at any moment. For most of us, this takes practice in the form of meditation, as our ego resists.
About craving and your book, it works because shows you a separation of craving and you. Allowing you to be aware of craving without having to act upon it. Because you learn it is not the true You.
This idea can be of help, besides the regular therapy or book, to free yourself of suffering.
If you would like to know more, I can recommend the teaching of the Buddha or Ramana Maharshi:
https://johndavidsatsang.international/illusion-and-the-body...
This is also what the Upanishads start with that you're not the body, nor mind nor thoughts, but the Atman. It branches differently from Buddhism and goes further connecting the Atman to the Brahman (universal reality). Both of these however start out the same and even realizing the start of that journey is a very big shift in how most of us live our daily lives.
It is very difficult to look or feel otherwise once you grasp this fundamental concept that a lot of spiritual texts teach.
Is a computer not a computer because it can't rewrite every mobo chip? This argument is asserting that there can't be autonomous parts to a whole.
If it is autonomous it remains beyond your control does it not?
I reject the premise that total control over X is a prerequisite for being X.
The above line of thinking leads itself ad absurdum resulting in "you" being nothing, not existing. We're supposed to accept this sleight of hand as deep wisdom? I prefer to interpret it as a hint at an error in the reasoning, personally. But you do you.
The computer does not have a subjective experience of self.
Maybe the computation is not the computer?
The Turing Machine’s tape stretches out into infinity, even while the piddling computer is finite.
Every mobo chip was written on a computer. What are you talking about?
I agree with the general idea, having OCD it's a lesson that was important for me to learn to cope with the condition, but I don't think anxiety or pain is something that is just negative and to be avoided. They might not subjectively feel good, but they serve a function, for survival. A sane mind could very well still choose to feel anxiety, because it fuels actions that help us survive.
A really good interview of Eckhart Tolle can also bring the point across:
https://youtu.be/ObAGAUJ08Vk?is=Z36fijPppfo9GRIJ
That seems backwards to me - fundamentally all that you are is emergent from your physical body, because literally what else is there? Yes to a degree you can ‘rise above’ your physical condition, but even ‘mind over matter’ is a bit of a misnomer when your mind is matter. Your awareness of the external world is sorely comprised of your physical senses, and even your inner world is largely a loop of ruminating on sensory input. What ‘you’ are is the experience of the present, and it’s not happening anywhere but your body.
> You are not them, because you can't control them.
Why should this be?
I think this might be two different questions, asked from two different domains.
When you look at a human being from the outside, of course, everything there is is the physical body. In fact, you can do away with the idea of a “soul“ or “mind” entirely and simply study the behavior. This is what BF Skinner did. And it works amazingly well.
But when you ask from inside, looking at yourself as an automaton or an animal to be conditioned, might not be helpful. It might be more helpful to see the urges, desires, anxieties as responses, which are not you, but are merely happening to you, observed by you.
The two views sound very different. But at the same time, they might be just different perspectives onto the same thing.
> fundamentally all that you are is emergent from your physical body, because literally what else is there?
This is perfectly valid if you firmly reject the existence of, say, a soul. But the experience of people who have died and returned, or has NDEs, suggests that there is more than just a physical body.
> What ‘you’ are is the experience of the present, and it’s not happening anywhere but your body.
People who've had out of body experiences would beg to differ. You can say that they are all imagining things - and it is plausible - but quite unlikely that people from different continents all experience very similar things.
> This is perfectly valid if you firmly reject the existence of, say, a soul. But the experience of people who have died and returned, or has NDEs, suggests that there is more than just a physical body.
I don't think those experiences require something other than the body necessarily. It's possible that everything that makes you "you" could be your brain state stored as neuron connections and neurochemistry. Then it's possible that if you're dead for a short period of time such brain state is preserved.
Right, except this true self isn't truly accessible all the time, is it? I don't think it's the case for everyone at least, because the "fake self" is made of things that have roots in your history as a person, and most people need to rely on these until they learn better. And for many people (most?), I believe this is a lifetime journey.
Also, I don't believe it's possible to free yourself from suffering, to me it makes more sense to accept and sublimate rather than eliminate it.
Thanks for the thoughts.
True, for most people, including myself, we are on a journey without end. Our conditioning is strong, so be it. The journey of enlightenment is like a compass: it points you to the direction of the North, yet you will never arrive at the final place called North, because this place does not exist. Despite this, a compass is still of use. My understanding is that the core is 3 A's: awareness, acceptance and appreciation.
Every moment holds the possibility for enlightenment
I do control (at least) my body and my thoughts and I am a triune being of body, mind and spirit.
Body being the physical actuator, mind being the conscious thoughts and spirit, being an integral part of my true self, what outlasts even amnesia.
I don't become another being if my body changed and I lost my memory. It'd still be the same me but I'd start adopting and forming a new identity and personality - or shape back into the preexisting one if the memories started came back.
In contrast, what I understood from your post, if my true me was only my "awareness of myself," I'd completely lose myself in a temporary state of amnesia without possibly of finding it back - unless someone else, in my concept that'd be a godly creature in the spiritual realm, was able to hold on to some state of my mind for me and hand it back (assigning the void *pointer back to my body instance) - but I'm not sure how that transfers to Buddhism.
>I do control (at least) my body and my thoughts
Can you NOT think of a pink elephant? Can you choose your next thought or the thought after that? I know you can cultivate an intention to think about a certain topic or and that when you do think the thoughts they feel "yours" and like they are being "generated" by you. But to go from that to a claim of "control" over thoughts there is a huge gap.
See also Peter Ralston: Ending Unnecessary Suffering: How to Create a Powerful, Complete, and Peaceful Life He's got some podcasts out which are worth trying.
The Buddha was cool an all. And I did find eastern zen writings poetic and inspiring.
But it seems to me like just another religion but of a different flavour.
I've met a few New Age types who would probably interpret pain, anxiety and cravings as messages from the universe as guidance.
To me all belief systems are just that. Belief. If it does the believer good (without harming them or others) then I guess it's probably ok for them.
This is largely in line with Tim Galwey's "Inner Game" books [0] specifically and Zen in general.
After reading many of Gallwey's books and also Zen and the Art of Archery [1], I would summarize it all down into one sentence:
Western coaching focuses on telling your body what to do, Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.
e.g. this story from the Inner Game of Skiing [2] summarizes it well:
"I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them:
- observe the angle of your skis to the ground
- flat on the ground is 1
- as far over as you can tilt is 10
- just feel what angle you are at as your are moving down the hill.
A young lady then came up to ask me 'So what is the correct angle??'. I told her 'There is no correct angle, just observe what angle your skis are.' "
If you prefer a video example, this youtube video of Gallwey teaching people hit play tennis for the first time is great [3] (note: it's very low video quality but excellent at showing his techniques).
0 - Gallwey's books: https://link.amazon/B00K1eqwt
1 - Zen and the Art of Archery https://link.amazon/B0326PLb7
2 - Inner Game of skiing https://link.amazon/B0igf0GrK
3 - Gallway teaching tennis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieb1lmm9xHk
I’m realizing much of good advice comes down to simply paying attention to whatever you want to improve. The progression is an artifact of that attention.
I guess attention really is all you need.
I have always been able to maintain a tiny coach in my brain while coding. Might have come from cycling. I saw similar notions when studying meditation. It’s also reflected in some martial arts, and in Slow is Smooth, Smooth is Fast.
Unfortunately there are other aspects of my life where the little coach never showed his stupid face.
I’m curious how you think about “a tiny coach” while coding. I’m having a hard time thinking about this in the context of the broader discussion.
How is my pace and how is my form? You’ve been working on this for five minutes and it should have taken 30 seconds. Why? That thing you did earlier today resulted in a red build. Why? Is this a me problem, and I need to shift how I work, or is this an us problem and we need a tool or a code/process change to stop it?
Lack of introspection tends to result in a lack of grace for coworkers, and I find it tends to hamper process and runbook improvements, because these people insist that only idiots make those sorts of mistakes, while working overtime to paper over their own. They have in effect begun to believe their own public relations material. The emperor has no clothes.
As one example, I often find that while developing I will make a mistake but catch it before committing, or at least before the PR. I count this toward my priority estimator for tech debt/DX effort. When junior developers or infrequent visitors to that same part of the code don’t catch the same error before someone else witnesses it, I now have empirical proof that this piece of code is a footgun. And by then I’ve already been making plans A and B for what to do about it, while waiting for builds, meetings, walking to lunch…
If your lead is almost making a mistake, that’s cause for concern. If others are making it, then that concern is founded.
> paying attention to whatever you want to improve.
the power of being aware of the feedback loop in your brain/body. hovering above those layers give you new perspective.
See also: Gurdjieff’s self-remembering state.
Attention is not all you need but you definitely can’t learn without it.
> Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.
Isn't this basically how learning works for most physical things? Riding a bike, swimming, etc..
I just came back from a bunch of icy hiking in Salt Lake City (KubeCon was last week). I wanted to climb a bunch of mountains but I had no gear except rubber sole hiking sneakers. Almost every place I went had slippery ice and steep inclines, but it was all no problem. That would be Bell Canyon upper falls, Heugh's Canyon, Neff's Canyon to the meadow, Grandeur Peak from Church Fork, Lake Blanche, Donut Falls and Frary Peak. Some of these were done in the rain or after snow.
You very quickly get used to what type of traction you get on certain types of surfaces and then you make small adjustments to improve stability. It's all trial and error and very dynamic. Maybe at the start you grab bushes for extra precaution, or you go super slow, or you crab walk down just to get a feel for how your footwear interacts with the ground.
How you shift your weight along with how much of your sneaker has contact on the ground play a big factor but it's not something you can easily explain, you just need to do it and see how it goes.
The dangerous part is walking downhill. When you test the friction for the next step you're taking, you shift your center of balance too much forward and compromise the traction of the other leg. And sometimes it's not even the shoe losing traction, but the ground you stepped on slides under pressure. That's why it's good to have better traction options available when you already start sliding somewhere.
I found after a while, the tests were done visually. Looking for the spots with the most grooves or little pieces of terrain to anchor the front of your foot on. If something didn't pop out immediately, I took it slower and evaluated the surrounding area to assess the risk in case I slipped. It was like going through a flow chart in real-time.
I slipped twice after ~260,000 steps where 80% of those steps were going uphill or downhill on mountains with a lot of mixed terrain (mud, running water, stepping on rocks over a creek, icy inclines, etc.).
Keep in mind, the two slips were I actually fell on my butt. I had a bunch of wobbly moments where it was possible to recover without falling. Basically the "learning" for me was trusting my body to be comfortable with a bunch of micro-slips where you can feel the ground shift below you, but by the time you take your next step, it recovers.
just buy some microspikes next time
Try wearing converse on ice
Sometimes, there’s just not enough friction
If you’re standing still but still moving, you have failed the minimum required friction.
The thing with ice is that you often hurt yourself by stubbornly trying not to fall down, making it uncontrolled when you do. Watching glacier mountaineers is quite informative of how often my instincts are counterproductive.
Try twisting the ankle perpendicular to the step to generate that extra friction.
Source: converse wearer in Canada
About Zen and the Art of Archery, the author was a naive and enthusiastic cultural tourist and the book should be consumed with this in mind.
Can you elaborate? Not sure in which way this should invalidate the book
Sure, check out the Myth of Zen and the Art of Archery:
Eugen Herrigel’s “Zen in the Art of Archery” has been widely read as a study of Japanese culture. By reconsidering and reorganizing Herrigel’s text and related materials, however, this paper clari³es the mythical nature of “Zen in the Art of Archery” and the process by which this myth has been generated. This paper ³rst gives a brief history of Japanese archery and places the period at which Herrigel studied Japanese archery within that time frame. Next, it summarizes the life of Herrigel’s teacher, Awa Kenzõ. At the time Herrigel began learning the skill, Awa was just beginning to formulate his own unique ideas based on personal spiritual experiences. Awa himself had no experience in Zen nor did he uncondi- tionally approve of Zen. By contrast, Herrigel came to Japan in search of Zen and chose Japanese archery as a method through which to approach it. The paper goes on to critically analyze two important spiritual episodes in “Zen and the Art of Archery.” What becomes clear through this analysis is the serious language barrier existing between Awa and Herrigel. The tes- timony of the interpreter, as well as other evidence, supports the fact that the complex spiritual episodes related in the book occurred either when there was no interpreter present, or were misinterpreted by Herrigel via the inter- preter’s intentionally liberal translations. Added to this phenomenon of misunderstanding, whether only coincidental or born out of mistaken inter- pretation, was the personal desire of Herrigel to pursue things Zen. Out of the above circumstances was born the myth of “Zen in the Art of Archery.”
I read The Art of Setting Stones shortly after Zen and the Art of Archery. If you’re into landscaping at all, I think it’s a good bookend for the other.
https://www.stonebridge.com/catalog/the-art-of-setting-stone...
Both are available in ebook form, not sure about audiobooks.
Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance is an homage to Zen and the Art of Archery, for those who didn’t know.
Thanks, I read The Inner Game of Tennis when I was young - and watching [3] just now reminded once again me of the core ideas. Letting go, (re)discovering the joy of letting your body do the right thing, these are all things I've suppressed for too long with "programmer's mind". Sometimes the hyper-analytical thing that works so well for us is the very thing that blocks us.
Fascinating stuff. This also chimes with how the great Keith Johnstone would teach improv, by thinking less.
Or Michel Thomas, for language learning.
Paying attention to what your body is doing is a good way to screw up anything you're trying to do. Paying attention to your thoughts is the same, it turns you inward and you become awkward and weird. This stuff is nonsense.
Sounds like the typical trap: you first need to separate the inner judge from the inner observer. Otherwise you just take your bully for a tour.
It is hard practice for those with adverse childhood experiences and the resulting internalized criticism to eventually be able to be aware of something without the negative stream of judgment and the subconscious desire to change and control it.
You either learn to tame the judge, or you have it act out on your environment, or more directly towards yourself. Your choice.
Book recommendation: Sarah Peyton, Self-Resonance.
Jiddu Krishnamurti: On Awareness https://kfoundation.org/krishnamurti-the-first-and-last-free...
“Therefore introspection and awareness are entirely different. Introspection leads to frustration, to further conflict, for in it is implied the desire for change and change is merely a modified continuity. […]
Perhaps what you’re describing is more related to a sense of insecurity or shame (or the act of overanalysing) than mere raw attention.
There is a fine line between observing and scrutinizing
Counterpoint: athletes.
And musicians.
> Paying attention to your thoughts [...] turns you inward and you become awkward and weird
Really, to whom did that happen? Tell us more please of the story!
I suppose this refers to (debilitating) self-consciousness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-consciousness#Impairment
I think there’s a point to be made here but there’s also a difference between practice and performance. During practice, awareness is super important. During performance, it’s more about intuition and muscle memory developed from that practice. At least for me, this is based on years of being a touring drummer in a band. I imagine athletes are the same. I wouldn’t call it nonsense though. Everybody’s different and every activity requires different things of you.
I became familiar with The Inner Game of Tennis via a presentation by Alan Kay, who now seems like a distant echo from a bygone age, when computing technology was really intended as a tool to aid and augment human capability, rather than the jester in Thus Spoke Zarathustra as it dances and sparkles over and past us. In the presentation, Kay provides a short clip of that exact news story featuring Gallwey working with Molly, and notes that after the first few times saying "hit", Molly's arm begins to move despite her not yet intending to actually hit the ball!
I've noticed a similar phenomenon in martial arts. When I focused less on making my body do the correct technique, and instead imagined wireframe fighters similar to the ones in Smash Bros. games attacking me, and the technique I was performing was a countermove—I found that thinking about the imaginary opponent rather than my own body made my technique more correct, as my peers and instructors had noticed.
> I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them: observe the angle of your skis to the ground
Oh interesting. This is very similar to how I was taught technical 4x4 driving: rather than obsessing over where the car or the trail is, simply pay attention to where each tire is and how it’s interacting with the terrain.
On difficult river crossings and boulder-strewn trails, developing that awareness made a world of difference. Once I could intuitively track all four tires, navigating obstacles became almost automatic. It felt like 95% of the skill.
I read Allan Carr's The Easy Way To Stop Smoking in 1999. I read it in one sitting while smoking a pack of cigarettes, and when I finished the book I never smoked again.
It has been 27 years, so I don't remember the details of the book and may be getting it wrong, but my takeaway was that the book circumvented all of the excuses your brain comes up with to start smoking again. It's like a nicotine craving sends a message to your brain, which comes up with an excuse to allow you to smoke again. For example, about four hours into "quitting smoking", your brain starts coming up with stuff like: "I'll just cut down to 6 a day", or "Maybe today isn't the best day to quit", or "I'll just smoke on weekends", or "I'll start smoking menthols", or "I'll just have one now and see if I can make it through the rest of the day", and then you're right back where you started. The book had an answer for all of these off-ramps, and made it clear that they were all created by nicotine cravings.
Hmm, I wouldn't really say that's the takeaway of "Easy way to quit smoking" that really resonates with smokers. In fact, i'd say it's the opposite message the book lays out.
This article is suggesting you have to "battle" your cravings, to stop smoking.
The books message is the opposite. It's seeing that you gain nothing from cigarettes, that they have created the solution to a problem they themselves created. It's seeing that there is nothing to "give up". There is no battling your cravings.
In fact, you have already lost if you are battling your cravings, because you are giving power to that thing. You are affirming that you are having to "give up" something by battling through the cravings, surely there must be some value in that thing because it's so hard to give it up.
No, there isn't. There is no battle.
I agree you shouldn't focus on your cravings, you should forget about them, by focusing on something else. Then the cravings gradually diminish. But "observing the craving" can also mean you are craving less, because you are experiencing more the process of observing, rather than experiencing the craving so badly. It's a tricck of the mind I believe.
The point is to understand that mechanism: You crave bad things not because of what you get from them in the end, but because of the excitement you feel when you are "reaching out" for them. It feels like something very valuable, is within your reach, and that gives you a great sense of excitement, which we enjoy. We want to stay in such a state, because moving away from it would make us feel we are giving up something very valuable.
I guess that is why people get addicted to gambling.
I underwent an operation in hospital and they wouldn't let me drink anything for a long time before the operation. I wanted to drink so badly that I came up with a plan in my head: Once I get out of this hospital I will refrain from drinking a whole day, just to be able to experience how good it feels when you then are actually able to drink.
Of course no such thing happened once I got out of the hospital, because I no longer had that enormous desire to drink anything. So I didn't feel the need to make myself thirsty just to be able to quench my thirst.
> But "observing the craving" can also mean you are craving less, because you are experiencing more the process of observing, rather than experiencing the craving so badly. It's a tricck of the mind I believe.
Yeah, I 100% agree with this. It's the basis for https://urgesurfing.org/ (just an mp3 file with someone talking through the act of 'surfing' an urge) which is a nice tool I've used before for getting used to the act of disassociating the craving from yourself in a way.
and a core part of the book is also some kind of brainwashing. The message that smoking is bad and therefore nothing to be given up is more or less repeated over and over probably a 100 times.
Ya, I think it's why it also encourages you to continue smoking as you read the book. Really baste in that badness
I think they meant it more as a bettle of “propaganda”.
The side with the better appeal will win the battle.
So it is not a battle of willpower but of perspective.
I think the missing part is the something you do instead.
I didn't stop chewing my fingernails. I started clipping them.
There's an industry of organizations that run "porn addiction" recovery programs. I think it's irrelevant whether or not you believe watching porn is a good it bad thing to do. The question that these organizations never answer is, "What should you do instead?" The implication is that people who want to stop watching porn should become asexual. Not only is that ridiculous, it demonizes the person's sexuality - a core part of their self - which gives an extreme amount of power and salience to the subject of avoidance; and pits them in a duel against their own self.
There is no victory without a victory condition.
While I agree with most of the article, I gotta add that Allen Carr’s method is not fool-proof.
The first read through is magical in its obviousness and simplicity. It works for a lot of people, which will praise it as if magic. But if by any chance you fall into the trap of smoking again, the book will have lost 90% of its power, simply because you have seen your cravings overcome its message once.
It’s taken me 10 more years after first reading the book, using the conventional techniques of nicotine substitutes, to finally quit for good.
Yes, the technique for dealing with anxiety described here is pretty much identical:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lGa-jQJazpY
This stuff should really be taught in schools.
Acts form habits, whether for good or for bad. The mind and the body are one substance, two aspects of the same thing.
Every moment of your life, you are training as hard as any professional athlete. Training for what? To be exactly the person that you have become so far.
Quitting sugar is a funny example, because for many people, some of those craving feelings might be coming from the gut microbiome demanding more of what it wants. I had to cut out most sugars/simple carbs for gut health reasons and what do you know, the cravings vanished simultaneously with the other unpleasant symptoms.
Not saying that's the only driver for sugar cravings of course, the brain and gut are in dialogue.
What if quitting sugar for gut health reasons was the magic thing your body needed to hear to stop having cravings?
In other words, you're saying the sugar craving monster might be literal - there's literally a thing inside you that feeds on sugar and dies a little when you don't eat it, and that's why it's funny.
This is probably safe for your microbiome, which can do with less sugar eating bacteria if you don't eat much sugar.
This becomes OT but:
I read that apparently bacteria that is feeding on fiber will attack the colon and stomach(?) if they don’t get enough fiber.
So what I am asking myself is:
1. is this also the case with sugar?
2. if it is the case with sugar, does it lead to people getting miserable while trying to cut down on sugar what leads to more incentive to remove the feeling with a little hit of sugar -> leading to a kind of negative cycle?
It is indeed not willpower that steers the body most. The more the reasoning brain imposes will on the body, the more the body/unconscious protests by causing pain.
The art is instead to assure the body that all is fine, for example calming it by rithmic movements like walking or boxed breathing. After a while the body admits there's nothing it needs to fight for, the pain and cravings deminish.
It occurs to me that if craving can be addressed one-battle-at-a-time, the opposite may be true: procrastination (or resistance to positive change) can be addressed one tiny bite at a time? I’m not sure what that looks like but it seems like an inversion of the same idea? I’d like to know more about this.
Great comments on this thread, thanks all.
“Habits” was the first answer for me. Habits obviate the need to spend willpower on mundane things, so I get more of it to spend elsewhere. Second effect is that having accomplished several things first thing in the morning rewards me with dopamine, which creates a credible promise of more dopamine for other things. Procrastination is lack of belief in the future dopamine fix.
Start with habits. “Atomic habits” is a good starting point.
This is a common procrastination technique, yes! Doing even just 10 minutes of work a day is a method people use, because it's just 10 minutes, it's next to impossible to say 10 minutes is too much work. And then you work up from there.
I tried this method until I burnt out. Laziness is actually unaddressed issues in a trench coat.
Yep - efficiency maxing is a curse that few recognise. I know I fail to recognise The benefits of taking a walking with no headphones, just relaxing to recharge, and sleep.
Laziness is like depression: a symptom of a larger problem, and a symptom shared by a lot of problems.
Like depression, it has a root cause, it doesn’t exist in a vacuum. It’s not a personality trait.
> Laziness is actually unaddressed issues in a trench coat
That’s a great line
Say more on that - what issues?
You should look into Tiny Habits from BJ Fogg, the head of Stanford's "Behavior Design Lab." This is precisely the idea and it really does work wonders. A few well-selected habits can totally transform one's life.
https://tinyhabits.com/book/
"you want to smoke because the craving feels bad, not because you actually want the cigarette."
This is an interesting assumption I often think about. The cigarette makes you feel different, or even better. Alcohol can do the same, it brings your mind in another state.
I'm not saying you should smoke or drink away your stress and anxieties but using a substance can be a positive experience, just like taking a run or have a fun night at a comedy club.
Should one only strive for positive experiences from natural effects, and if so, can I play GTA6 to feel better?
I think you're describing the difference between being addicted or not. For many addicts, most of the time that they choose to smoke or drink (or gamble, or shoot up, etc) it's because they want to assuage the discomfort of a craving.
They probably started on this path because of the good feelings associated with the drug, and they still enjoy those too, but they continue to do the drug even once the bad consequences outweigh the fun because of avoiding negative feelings.
Plenty of people drink or smoke only occasionally and choose to do so because of the positive effects, and those people aren't really the target of "The easy way to stop X" books.
Alcohol and tobacco are a bit complicated in how they act so let's pick a better drug for this example, amphetamines.
In simple terms, both GTA 6 (and food, sex, music, a "like" on a post) and taking amphetamines release dopamine. But playing a game doubles your dopamine vs the baseline, while amphetamines release 10x or more.
10x is too much dopamine and your brain will turn down its reward signaling so you may end up with tolerance, crashes, addiction. Also it's hard to fall asleep, which has its own cascade of problems.
But those specific substances can also produce cravings that are deeply unpleasant. Coffee also makes me feel good, but the worst withdrawal I might get is a headache that an Advil resolves.
This reminds me a lot of DNRS and Primal Trust, tools that are supposed to help with the mental shift in healing from Long Covid and other chronic illnesses.
The analogy that works for me is as follows:
1. Noticing and naming
There is a mental phenomenon, like tension, or craving, or distraction. It may not be obvious. The obvious name might be "back pain", or "cigarettes", or "stress". You first learn to notice and name a truer, primary cause. This is why it can work so fast. Sometimes, all you need to learn is that there is a truer primary cause for it to become obvious.
2. Shifting focus to an incompatible mental state.
The knowledge that pain is caused by tension is incompatible with a focus on injury. The mental representation of one negates the other. The focus on a neutral process of craving negates the belief about physical need. The knowledge of the process of distraction inhibits the focus on stressful distractors.
In the brain you're finding activations which inhibit the firing of undesirable neural activity. The exact mental state will vary by individual, which is why particular visualizations work so well for some and not others.
3. Practice
Through repeated practice of associating stimuli/experience with the truer more desirable mental state you learn the habit of going straight from the stimulus to the good state, bypassing the undesirable state. You inhibit the brains old prediction of the next link in the chain and replace it with a prediction of a better one.
Now the above works very well when there is a truer root cause than the one you've noticed in the past, but the crazy thing is that it works even if you can only convince yourself its a truer root cause. Even if your body really is damaged and is reporting as much with pain you can use the above (or similar meditation techniques) to master/overcome/ignore that pain, though it is harder and requires much more of the practice step.
There are two wolfs in you: The one that does wants what you should do and the one that wants what you crave. Which one is growing? The one you feed.
There's horrible animalistic inner conflict in me? I don't think so. If there's a wolf in me it's because I ate it. But let's put it like this: you can want things in a simple, emotive, dumb, heartfelt way, while simultaneously wanting conflicting things in a cognitive, reasoned, sophisticated, unpersuasive way. What to do?
My insight is: dumb drives care about what's easy and comfortable, therefore they have no input in sophisticated moral reasoning, and can't disagree with it. Their only message is that you function badly when uncomfortable. Therefore by consciously clearing the path to make the morally preferred things easy you can avoid inner conflict.
Inside you there are two wolves
https://i.redd.it/uhfyyxqtwu4e1.png
Interesting FT article about the usage of this method in person with a group of smokers:
"I have smoked about 250,000 cigarettes. This is how I quit" https://www.ft.com/content/8bc82ad7-625e-44a6-b582-4ffdfee72...
Wow, this is so interesting. My girlfriend and I just finished reading Allen Carr, which has helped a lot with anxiety. And the reason why I picked it up was because I thought anxiety might be amplifying or even causing physical pain. The fact that other people were able to overcome pain through mental motions gives me a lot of hope. Thanks for linking this.
If I'm interested in reading more about this without picking up books specific to smoking, tennis, and spiritually, is "The Experience Machine" by Andy Clark in the same vein?
Made me think of this anecdote from Harry Browne's book How I Found Freedom in an Unfree World:
> One night I had to give a lecture and she announced that she was going out with someone else. I was sure they’d wind up in bed — and it infuriated me. I didn’t want to stop her but I still felt terribly jealous. On the way to the lecture, I stopped for dinner. For the previous three hours, I’d been unable to think of anything but the terrible thing I was sure was going to happen. I finally decided that I wouldn’t be able to give the lecture unless I calmed down.
> After ordering my dinner, I started to use the technique. I had never seen the other man involved — which always seems to make such a person more formidable. So I pictured him as the exact opposite of me, the kind of man I wouldn’t like, the kind of man who could sweet-talk women away from their lovers. I imagined them doing together every obscene thing I could think of. 21 I was determined to keep thinking about the scene over and over again until it no longer bothered me emotionally. However, I suddenly realized that I was thinking about the lecture I was going to give; I hadn’t made it all the way through the imaginary sex scene even once. So I turned my mind back to the horrible scene and concentrated on it again.
> But it quickly became apparent that my mind had wandered once again. And then it dawned on me that the scene no longer held any terror for me — not even any interest, in fact.
> So I spent the rest of my dinner time planning my lecture and never gave the jealousy problem another thought. In all, it had taken only about five minutes of attention to eliminate all the pain and fear.
This reminds me of the centipede's dilemma: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Centipede%27s_Dilemma
Basically, you ask the centipede how he walks, he reflects on it, and loses the ability.
To listen to the full sssssstory: https://youtu.be/69ajDYBUsuo
It all sounds great but physical cravings can be deeply ingrained in your neuronal structure and can take a long time to get rid of. I wonder to what extent this is one of those things where once you do this it feels like a massive breakthrough, but then 2 months later you're back to where you started as if nothing happened.
More on this: https://chrislakin.blog/p/flaky-breakthroughs
Along similar lines: https://dianazink.com/brain-hours.html
I really like what the author wrote and I'm one of those people who was freed from their chronic back pains by just reading the first 60 pages of jon Sarnos book.
There are certainly a lot of truth in cure your body by mind but there are significant dangers in going too far. As a runner too often I push through the mental wall, sometimes it leads to far worse injuries. Same as a founder, I pushed through many times and the end results were not worth the cost. Balance is the key that I am yet to discover.
I think you're talking about "mind over matter" self-motivation more than thoughts and habits that cure.
I would assume someone who said he was cured just by reading the reviews was joking.
Most nonfiction books present zero to a handful of novel core concepts that could be described in a few pages and then spend the rest filling pages with anecdotes, the history of the discovery etc. that, while often interesting and entertaining, are not strictly necessary to convey that message at all.
I would actually find it much more surprising if a reportedly life-changing method, which can be implemented purely by changes in behavior, would work only if presented in a hundreds of pages but not in a couple of paragraphs. (And, to be very honest, I would probably also not spend $10 on a couple of paragraphs. That's not how I've learned to model the economics of buying and reading books :)
Sometimes you can get all the important insights from the reviews and don’t actually need to read the book, so maybe that’s what they meant.
Sometimes all it takes is one small tool in your toolbox to make a big change. As the song says, I am downright amazed at what I can destroy with just a hammer.
Maybe, but it's not completely implausible, either. If someone has written a review that contains exactly the right key point from the book, it's possible.
I don't find it implausible at all.
Consider how concisely some hard-won scientific achievements could be presented to somebody from an earlier period. "Many illnesses are caused by omnipresent microorganisms that can be killed by heat, alcohol, and soap" sent back through time alone could, if believed, save billions, completely experimentally and without any theory of cellular life, bacteria etc.
Why shouldn't the same hold for psychological techniques as well?
Americans struggle with satire I find.
Haha thought you were serious for a sec. USA! USA!
Bald eagles crescendo!
For me, what I think of as ”you“ is not a tiny homunculus in my head which steers the rest of me with commands and controls. “You“ are not in control, “you” is a crowd of competing impulses and memories, with a thin mask on it that lets you imagine yourself as the boss.
It seems like reading some of these ideas helps the reasoning brain discover the correct signal to send out to the unconscious mind to make something happen. And in a remarkably abstract way - the reasoning brain can receive a message like "it's all in your head" and (if conditions are right) discover the signal that suppresses certain back pain.
Great article I first heard about Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind through Steve Jobs. Just finished reading it and gained so much from it. Even though I struggle to meditate every single day, I truly believe sticking with it will pay off immensely.
Good article and worth internalizing before a crisis occurs.
Mind over matter is a futile battle. Your body and all of its autonomous systems can't be neglected. Learn to work together or suffer the consequences.
Over 20 years ago I quit smoking after being a pack and a half smoker since high school. I didn’t torture myself by trying to quit, by cutting down or using some aid like nicotine alternatives.
Instead, I simply ran through a simple mental exercise every time I started a cigarette. I imagined and felt the few things that I really didn’t like about smoking - the look and smell of an old full ashtray, the taste of a stale cigarette, the gagging feeling of a first daily cigarette one sometimes experiences, the feeling of smoke in my eyes etc. Every cigarette every time, and after that I would just carry on with my cigarette. I didn’t try to give up smoking.
After a few weeks I realized I was often stubbing out the cigarettes early, not through a conscience decision! A few weeks later I just … stopped wanting a cigarette, and haven’t wanted one since.
Today, for the first time I hear of Allen Carr’s technique. It’s not the same, but related and I’m amazed I never heard of it! Both it seems result in changing one’s core beliefs?
One note of warning: I think this technique could be really dangerous if applied to things like overeating etc.
Another important point I think is that I was in an environment conducive to stopping smoking - my wife hated it. If your in an environment where smoking is rewarded, like for example smoking with a buddy, or regular pub sessions, it surely would be less effective.
If anyone wants more info or advice on this, email me.
This is effectively Alan Carrs method in his famous book. I just listened to half of it on audiobook (on YouTube, no less) and quit smoking too, years ago.
I would guess cravings get worse for awhile, then slowly better. I think most people get stumped on the part where the cravings get worse.
> The same thing happens with John Sarno’s book, Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection.
This was me, flat on my back, pretty much paralyzed in bed from pain from moving in any direction. I bought the book on my tablet and started reading, got to the part about how I was doing it exactly wrong, and that getting up and moving is the way out. That was a starter's pistol for me. I hobbled my way out of back pain and that has been my first resort ever since.
I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.
Yes- but all has to be in moderation and as a combination of treatments. I get people telling me all the time to do wild things which ignore the slip disks will hurt in the days after, sure I can do it in the moment but I will pay for it.
>I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.
The woo woo with Sarno is in the physiological explanations that he gives for pain (ostensible oxygen deprivation which turns out to not be the case), but subconscious self sabotage is a fairly sound explanation for what's going on.
In Adlerian psychology this is usually framed as the teleogy rather than the etiology of pain, anxiety and so forth. Ask what is the purpose of pain or anxiety, not its cause. We often maintain pain or anxiety because its a safety mechanism. You don't stay home because you suffer from pain or are anxious, the pain or anxiety protects you from change.
Nice techniques. And you can also let go of steering altogether. Here's an apt fight club scene for the compulsive self optimizing, self improving control freaks out there.
https://youtu.be/38FMDG7tiA4?is=2d-Vd9CWJIHsJzWK
I've been learning about reoccurring pain, lethargy or illness in the body and that these symptoms can occur in response to trauma (often repressed)- its a sign that emotions are stuck and need to be allowed/worked through.
Dale Carnegie's book How to Stop Worrying and Start Living is full of such anecdotes.
Sounds like mindfulness which formalised this practice. Maybe I've misunderstood it?
There are MANY eastern things(not just philosophies) like patanjali yogasutras that is the framework for this, & is basically are cures for a great life, but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way
"but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way"
Hehe, that reminds me about the hype about chinese medicine. That was largely not understood in china at all, as to them it was old not working medicine and the modern medicine obviously better.
In other words I disagree that western audiences need a western presentation in general it can be the opposite, the mysticism of the ancient asian traditions are part of the package (never mind that most "ancient" traditions are in reality just decades old and just new interpretations of old teaching)
In fact the west is so lost to this propaganda that they even blind themselves to western esoteric info. Most of the west thinks santa is fake lmao! They don't understand the meaning of philosophy, mythology, story & theory & differences between them.
Yup, most of the eastern world is westernized since the invention of nation states & doesn't even know how to use eastern stuff. HN is at its lowest of information & intelligence in my past 20 years spent here.
"hype about chinese medicine"?????
It saved my life when Western med couldn't do shit.
Care to share what happened?
the downvotes prove the point :)
stare at bellybutton stare some more keeping staring
you have reached nirvana
Try this with time: Every time you feel the need to check what time it is, make a quick guess before looking at the clock.
This is such bullshit. Pain is a physical signal from your body telling you that a part of you is compromised.
I believe that you can train yourself to ignore pain, but that's literally a last resort. And my experience with this was that the pain just manifests in other ways, like anxiety.
Call me ancient but I think that the reverse is true, it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse
Yeah. I twisted my ankle badly about 2 years ago, for a middle aged guy anyway, and no amount of positive thoughts helped putting weight on the ankle for at least a month.
Even then recovery was at least 3 months.
Chronic pain often is not a useful signal. Consider that there is little correlation between back pain and what MRI or whatever modern diagnostic can show. One person where the diagnostic shows that nothing is wrong may suffer daily. Another with spine discs that are obviously damaged may suffer very little.
The same is with damaged meniscus. One can run with no pain. Another suffers at each walking step. Sometimes an operation can help, but it is rather invasive with non-trivial risk of complications. And given that meniscus does not heal by itself if a person can learn not to feel the pain, it can greatly improve quality of life.
Pain is often a meaningful signal, but it can be psychosomatic as well in some cases. However, I do applaud your concluding observation that, basically, healing the body can heal the mind. Mind and body communicate in both directions and to heal or develop must work together.
>it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse
Mental issues are eliminated when one stops giving them much importance and pretty much ignores them. Its known since ancient times that mind can only add and multiply, there is no subtraction. In the east they say "mind is like a still lake's water, to calm down the ripples all you have to do is wait, any attempt to counter them will only cause more".
But the big problem here is ego, if we think our thoughts and emotions are very valuable, they "make us who we are" and other modern age bullshit, we will have hard time getting rid of them.
For physical issues you got to a doctor and they do what they can, that's about it.
It depends. Pain receptors aren't precise because we are messy bags of protein. They necessarily start doing their thing before actual damage has happened. In those scenarios you can judiciously ignore pain that will not cascade into lasting injury.
I fixed my RSI by reading a book so yeah, useful schmuseful.
yeah right
and we all find nirvana...
I guess this is why even crippling social anxiety tends to dissipate in cases where the activity being engaged is thoroughly more interesting
This blog post cured my back pain
...to quit smoking
Often in life, your body is the one steering you. And sometimes, to get to do the thing you want, you can’t just convince yourself with reason or arguments, or will yourself, or do the exercises to get there - you need to learn the magic formula, the secret words, to trick the body into acting in a way that gets you the outcome you want.
Sometimes we need to find a way to steer the body, and the body only listens when you say the magic words. I like these examples, not only because they are all actually powerful and useful, but also because it feels like I am whispering the secrets of the universe - that through saying the magic words, I am being granted special root access to my own programming.
Modern humans reinventing the bicameral mind from first principles. This is a golden retriever's inner monologue seeing a treat being held out and hearing "sit"