Fiber is so much better than cable in an emergency. The equipment consumes significantly less power and is likely to stay up longer during a power outage. You get way more customers on each battery / generator.
I had an FTTH provider with 100% of their network on natural gas standby generators. Went through a week long power outage without losing a single packet. You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power. There are homes with larger generators than this. Docsis 4 would put you somewhere around half a megawatt.
On an ongoing basis, no, but some appliances (especially air conditioning) have significant inrush current. Off grid systems have to be designed to either do without those or be able to handle them, even if for just 200ms. TBH I'm not familiar with gas/propane generators, but if their nameplate capacities significantly oversell their ability to handle sudden inrush currents without losing a lot of voltage then I could see how you could end up with a home with a bigger generator. I'm much more familiar with battery inverter setups, which suffer the same problem but at least if they say then can do split phase at 12kW if you actually ask it for 12kW at 240v you're generally going to get 240v.
Though installing a soft start goes a long way to helping reduce that need, regardless of which technology is used.
Holy moly! Here in Italy, the average residential power supply is around 3.3 kW. It might be a bit higher nowadays, but now I understand why in movies you always see the mad scientist working in the basement surrounded by heavy equipment!
You will generally not use anywhere near that much simultaneously. Cooking ranges are wired with 50A nowadays, but you'd have to use all (four) elements at 100% as well as be (pre-)heating the oven at the same time to even get close to that.
Clothes dryers are usually 30A, and external AC units are in the 30A range as well for a medium unit.
You'd be having to do a lot of things all at once to even get close to 100A, never mind 200A.
There are induction ranges that can saturate the circuit without all burners being on. The software is responsible for handling power distribution to accommodate.
and there are others that come with battery packs that you install underneath them in order to be able to max out all of the "burners" simultaneously without overloading the circuit.
We have breakers on every individual circuit. You won't blow the whole house by running a coffee maker and a hairdryer at the same time, but you will blow that single circuit if you run them both on it simultaneously.
A whole house breaker is 100, 150, now 200A minimum in new builds for single family homes. My 1br rental apartment from the 90s has 100A service.
Just because we only have one main circuit coming into the house doesn't mean you have to be careful not to run the vacuum and the stove at the same time...
I couldn't imagine only having 3.3kW for a normal home. A normal electric oven/stove combo here can easily use 10kW+ of peak power, assuming you're using four burners and the oven. And you haven't even turned on a blender or used any hot water yet.
During the heat wave over the summer my AC was using about 4kW of power on its own, and that's just the compressor outside.
Lots of Brits will use 3kW just heating their tea.
Yep, that's exactly how many Italian households operate.
The unwritten rule is: if someone is using the hairdryer, nobody touches the oven, washing machine, or vacuum cleaner.
Things are getting better with more efficient appliances and higher-capacity contracts, but for a long time "What can I turn on without tripping the breaker?" was a daily consideration.
Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me. That's more than the entire standard power allowance of many Italian homes!
> Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me.
That's often on start-up. I'm in an older Canadian house with 'only' a 100A service, and when the external AC unit kicks on there's often a flicker to lights. (Often with vacuum too.)
It might be a good idea for me to install a soft start device (which would also probably help with unit longevity):
Nah, ~16-18A @ 240V running for a 5-ton rated AC unit when its hot out were the measurements I took when servicing it this summer before the heat really hit. The nameplate actually rates the unit for ~27 RLA (Rated Load Amps) with an LRA (Locked Rotor Amps) at about 140A.
Its usually pretty common to hit anywhere between 60-80% RLA during a normal summer day.
> Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me. That's more than the entire standard power allowance of many Italian homes!
Questo perché hanno case mal isolate, troppo grandi e usano condizionatori a tecnologia obsoleta, senza inverter, che possono solo funzionare a 100% (e se gli va bene hanno un secondo stage a 50%).
Oh no, la mia casa è troppo grande? Che problema terribile. Magari potessi vivere in una scatola da scarpe.
Lots of time of the yeary system runs almost exclusively it's second stage. An inverter unit wouldn't do much for me but increase my upfrontcosts considerably while reducing reliability. The way the climate is here, a two stage unit is plenty of variability. It doesn't take long for the heat to set in. You go from not needing any AC to wanting to crank it pretty quick. There's a bit of efficiency gains with an inverter unit, but it'll take most of the life of the unit to offset the cost difference with the price of electricity here.
I have a large woodworking and metalworking shop behind my single family home.
I have a transformer that serves only my shop :)
I use 800 amps of single phase inverted into 200 amps of 480v 3 phase (the rest of the single phase is for the house and apartment above the shop)
I have 200kwh of battery as well.
This is definitely on the extreme side, but most woodworkers (and metalworkers) i know use 50kw total easily within their single family home garages. Once you get past portable tools, they really don't make tools with less than a 5hp motor because it would be more expensive and annoying.
ok but how much you actually use ? Even if every tool is 10kW (which would be pretty fucking powerful), you're using maybe that, few kW for dust extractor and waht else ?
Unless you have employees (and at that point, not really a house but business), how ?
Not a normal single-family home, maybe a complex with 20+ appartements, or a villa with multiple hot swimming pools, server room, plus attached housekeeper appartments...
> I can't imagine what a single-family home would do with 50kW of power.
Your average European SFH has anything from 25-50 kW of heating power for heating and warm water plus 22 kW of electrical load (3x32A @ 230V). Easy enough to do with natural gas or oil, but if you want to switch towards electricity as energy source with all the wars going on... you now need a whole lot of electrical generation capability to survive an outage in the winter, even with heat pumps.
(Don't get me started on the French, these fools need so many NPPs because they run straight resistive electrical heaters, what a waste compared to heat pumps)
25-50 kW of heating power is still massive. A somewhat decently insulated house can do with half of that.
I heat my house + provide hot water with a heat pump of 6 kW output. I do everything with electricity; before we had an EV and solar panels my yearly electricity consumption was something like 3400 kWh. Granted, that is with a very well insulated house and definitely below average but still, average houses here don't need anywhere close to 50 kW. You can't even get such a connection to the grid as a residential user; a standard connection is ~16kW although you can request a bit more.
> A somewhat decently insulated house can do with half of that.
Yeah but most homes in Germany (or, while we're at it, in France) aren't. As a result, we pay through our nose for oil and gas, and the French have to cross-fund EdF with its NPP boondoggles that explode in budget and come decades late.
> You can't even get such a connection to the grid as a residential user; a standard connection is ~16kW although you can request a bit more.
Huh what? 16 kW is about 3x20 amps, that's rare to see even for apartments these days. Standard I've seen in Bavaria for apartments is 3x25, SFH is 3x40 amps, some 3x50, and if it's a former farm site, 63, 80 or even 100 amps.
That is half a watt per connection? It sounds low to me. Considering with all other power needed for the gear. Fiber is efficient but it still sounds very low.
Most of AT&T's new residential fiber construction these days is passive. It also means you share a time-multiplexed connection with your neighbors just like the coax systems. You get periods of congestion.
> You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power
I feel like there's something wrong here; you're three orders of magnitude off. Many typical household appliances easily cross multiple kilowatts. For some scale: running a kettle, a washing machine at max temperature, a dishwasher, a microwave, a high-end gaming PC, and a conventional oven, all simultaneously, approaches a power draw of about 25 kW.
> For some scale: running a kettle, a washing machine at max temperature, a dishwasher, a microwave, a high-end gaming PC, and a conventional oven, all simultaneously, approaches a power draw of about 25 kW.
2.5 + 2.5 + 2.5 + 1 + maybe 3kW. How you got 25kW out of 11.5kW ?
While Comcast has deployed plenty of fiber throughout the US, its cable Internet service makes the final connection to homes with coaxial cable. This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds.
You can get symmetric DOCSIS, and apparently Comcast do offer that service[1]. Likewise, FTTH can be asymmetric if they set the traffic shaping that way. IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability. As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.
In fact, anecdotes from a few people I know have been that service interruptions actually increased after they upgraded to FTTH from DOCSIS.
> As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.
I get that attitude, but coax connections are fragile in a way that fiber is not. Water infiltration, bad crimping jobs, unterminated ends in the neighbor's house all cause signal degradation that is extremely time and labor intensive to identify and fix.
Cable is an excellent solution for distributing broadcast analog radio signals over a private line cheaply and efficiently, but two-way digital signals over the same medium aren't as robust as their fiber-based counterpart.
ISP outages are one thing, but if you ever experience service degradation—and not a full outage, but tear-your-hair-out crap like "my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern"—and it ends up being some particularly coax-flavored problem, you'll understand what I'm talking about.
my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern
Actually that's exactly the type of complaints I've heard from those who upgraded to FTTH. My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper, and installation and testing requires significantly more expensive equipment, although it is cheaper for longer distances and theoretically capable of higher bandwidth (but the transceivers on each end are also a significant part of the cost.)
Upgrading to fiber was the best thing I've ever done in terms of internet service. I've never heard of what you claimed. Myself and everyone I know, anecdotally, have had FAR better service reliability with fiber. Also, having massive upload capacity papers over other failings elsewhere in your tech stack, like a router that doesn't know how to properly queue. Well, throw a ton of bandwidth at it and there's no big queue backing up anyway.
The only time fiber has gone out for me, including power outages that impacted my home, was if a neighbor or another ISP was digging and cut my line. That said, this happened with coax, and would be a problem with anything except a WISP or Starlink.
Indeed, if I move and fiber isn't available but cable is, I'll probably just go Starlink. I'd rather deal with that variability than ghost-in-the-machine coax craziness.
The real life rates of these things happening to people is low. We humans remember these events precisely because they are not common. This is why each of you is adamant different solutions are better.
As for satellite I think I’d rather just not have internet than go that route. Maybe read more.
Is it possible you need to disclose some conflicts of interest here?
Fiber doesn't have the noise or attenuation issues that coax does. Having worked in the industry and monitored plant, things like daily temps, proximity to radio transmitters, water in the soil can all cause signal to noise issues with coax.
Fiber can snap very easily where's copper does not have this problem. Most of the time this is something only technicians could cause to begin with though.
Kind of a big wat to this whole post. I've never, ever heard, or experienced myself or with clients, anyone across three continents having anything less then a rock solid experience with FTTH. Only trouble has always been getting it installed in the first place.
>My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper
How did you reach that understanding? It's the opposite, fiber is a lot tougher particularly at high speeds. For outdoors I use stuff with a steel helix armor and then kevlar, you can direct bury it a few inches and drive a truck or tractor over it no problem. It's immune to electrical interference, you don't have to worry about surges to different ground potentials, water is no issue. People sometimes talk about bend radius but it's something like 10x diameter installed and 20x under tension (pulling) which is trivial given how thin fiber is. And high performance copper has a bend radius too, which isn't as high a multiple but simultaneous copper is a lot thicker.
>and installation and testing requires significantly more expensive equipment
On the installation side no, not sure what you'd be thinking of there. Pulling cable is pulling cable. On the testing side, sorta? A hobbyist who is just willing to redo things while they're learning can get away with cheap stuff, just like with ethernet. I guess it's true higher end testing equipment (like Fluke) ramps up faster than ethernet, higher floor, but the most serious kit is really expensive for both, and simultaneously is a fixed cost that is clearly meant for contracts that will pay it. Anyone spending $15k on a DSX ethernet kit is doing government or enterprise contracts or something where the cost will amortize out, same as with fiber.
The only area where there's a clear (but still one time) cost/irritation difference is if a cable is broken and needs to be spliced. But this too correlates with "if you're big enough to actually need to care the cost gets amortized".
>although it is cheaper for longer distances
Can't do long distances with high performance copper at all, setting aside cheaper (and yes copper has skyrocketed in price).
>and theoretically capable of higher bandwidth
Uh, "theoretically"? Fiber is much, much higher bandwidth, no theory about it.
>(but the transceivers on each end are also a significant part of the cost.)
A 20km class GPON (1G) transceiver new, no bulk pricing, starts around $40, and an XGPON (10G) around $50. SFP+ ones are less. Yes if you get into 100-800 Gbps class transceiver cost goes way up, but so does all the equipment one would use for that (100G is probably going to be at least $250/port last I checked) even before touching on whatever is actually making use of such a network. Transceiver cost would not be a significant part of overall project cost.
> IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability.
Latency, quality of networking gear, the experience of connecting devices, customer service, price of bundled services etc.
There is a lot that matters. As someone who’s worked in networking gear and both ISPs and customers, those who just want a connection and manage the rest are a minuscule percentage.
Almost everyone who buys a connection wants it to work perfect always and when not they want a simple step to fix it (like a reboot). Achieving this has a lot of moving parts.
To add more context: fiber allows for complete remote configuration and management. While docsis does have a lot of control it’s an old technology with lot less available for remote monitoring and configuration.
With fiber you can even change the WiFi password without ever having to connect to the WiFi. Yes that’s worse for privacy and security but it’s going to save you in hundreds of thousands of dollars in customer service calls.
This is TR-069 provisioning right? Pretty much all types of CPE support it, Fiber, DSL, DOCSIS. There's nothing specifically about fiber that makes it better or worse for remote provisioning, except maybe the hardware tends to be a lot newer.
Yes TR-069 and now omci with fiber. I’m not saying it’s not possible with docsis. Just that everything new with fiber is just more sensible and even affordable. Fiber is actually quite cheap in developing countries like India.
Hell, not even TR-069. It was fun to slide around the admin network of the ISP I was taking calls for and remote into the back end of cable (and DSL!) modems with the silly password of the day and just read out people's Wi-Fi passwords at them because they forgot it.
Pepperidge Farm remembers signing in as root/12345 to a looot of Comtrend ADSL crap, too.
I don't understand this point of distinction for a couple of different reasons:
I've remotely configured wifi services within end-user DOCSIS equipment; doing this was part of my job, and was part of a service that customers paid for
My FTTH connection at home terminates in a pretty dumb little box that does not have any wifi capabilities at all, and this box sits on the Internet-facing side of my firewall
DOCSIS cable modems weren't also routers or wireless access points until recently. All of the common fiber ONTs can be configured as such and typically are.
Today, you can buy a DOCSIS cable modem on Amazon with no router functionality and use it with any provider. You cannot select or provide a fiber ONT, use an SFP instead, etc. with any major residential provider.
> DOCSIS cable modems weren't also routers or wireless access points until recently.
The Motorola SURFboard SBG900 was released in 2003 and had B/G WiFi built-in. My own personal experiences in a few different markets and cable companies, they nearly all offered all-in-one modem/router/wifi gateways since I dunno, at least 2005-2006 or so. You could also get just a modem.
While you are correct that you can get symmetric on assymetric services on both (essentially that was possible before as well, if you went for e.g 100Mbit), docsis 4.0 itself is still asymmetric due to spectrum allocation, tx power, noise ... I think theoretically you can get 6/10G up/down. Does that matter right now? Probably not if you don't have noisy neighbors, however the long term upgrade path is very different and there are other disadvantages like latency, jitter, reliability... All of which people associate to be better with fiber, hence Comcasts advertises as fiber powered
Service. What I most value from my service provider is that I can get answers from them without being treated like a baby.
Last time I called my ISP (last year? the year before? I don't remember) I was wondering when I would get service back. The street had exploded, underground power cable threw a tantrum and tore a big hole in the road, the grid company come out and fixed that but then of course my Internet didn't come back once the lights did.
The person who answered my call:
+ Did not waste my time asking that I restart laptops, routers, etc. the diagnostic lights on the router indicate No signal => not a problem I can fix by rebooting things.
+ Without needing me to re-specify where I live went straight to the identified problem (DSLAM offline) and to the fault report (to last mile provider for a failed DSLAM) and told me that in their experience I should expect a fix on Sunday (it was Friday evening). Which is what happened.
I had an outage of my DOCSIS cable this morning. About 15 minutes after it went out I received a text from the provider that there was a known outage, with an ETA for a fix, and one for the next message to expect. It ended up coming back on after 45 minutes, but this was a decent experience.
I suspect the asymmetry is designed to prevent people from broadcasting/streaming. I bet it works about 98% of the time but hiccups when other people use it. Probably just enough to upsell you to commercial service. It also prevents people from having high traffic websites, again so they can sell you the solution. (I know cloudflare exists, but these systems were designed 20+ years ago)
You are overthinking this. DOCSIS 1.0 had asymmetric speeds baked into the standard in part because when it was designed the cable TV industry was beginning to switch to IPTV systems. Cable TV is highly asymmetric and so the networks were set up for asymmetric traffic patterns anyway; it made perfect sense to do the same for DOCSIS. At the time cable Internet service was competing with dialup ISPs, and nobody was hosting anything on a dialup connection so I doubt anyone was thinking about that.
The biggest motivation for modern cable ISPs to provision more upstream capacity for residential users was COVID. A lot of residential users were suddenly using Zoom/etc. all day long, and upstream throughput was a problem.
I've had to deal with way too many noisy neighbors on coax to ever want to deal with that again. Too many times of unexplainable drops in signal quality that can never be replicated in the 10 minute window when a tech shows up days later. You just realistically don't get that with almost all residential fiber deployments.
I never want to have to deal with copper networking I can't completely control.
Comcast is indeed starting to offer symmetric DOCSIS. I recently saw my upload speed move from a completely useless 35 Mbps to a more reasonable 2350 Mbps. The Comcast tech really did not want to upgrade my DOCSIS 3.1 modem to a DOCSIS 4.0 modem, which was required for upload speeds to exceed 400 Mbps, but they thankfully did. The previous modem didn't even support Wi-Fi 7. (Though I now thankfully use this one in bridge mode. What a relief -- I hope to never touch their mandatory fucking mobile app ever again.)
Note that I had to make an FCC false advertising complaint earlier this year before they would upgrade my area. You should try it, the executive who contacted me was surprisingly willing to drill into the control structures to figure out what was going on.
Back in the days of rolling out U-Verse (their FTTN service), AT&T's advertising used exactly the same strategy of weasel-words to say "fiber" without making an actionable implication that it was fiber from A to Z. Phrases like "fiber rich network" and "U-Verse uses fiber optic technology."
I also got Cox's "fiber" and was really confused when they told me to reuse my DOCSIS modem. Didn't get symmetric speeds, but at least upload was a lot better than before.
I came here to say the same thing, I remember getting an ad for "U-Verse" and being like "omg fiber???" and then did their online check to see that it was basically DSL.
This would make a lovely amicus curiae, if someone were to raise such, on Comcast’s behalf. Not that I think it’s worth the time — they can both rot as far as I’m concerned — but if you want to see AT&T get a bit of fuck around find out energy in a federal lawsuit, a judge would probably quite value an expert opinion prepared to federal court standards. I could very well see them ruling that the lowest-provisioned segment of delivery between the CO and the terminal must be the transport method and capacity advertised, so that they can’t just run FTTH from an ISDN line or call a radio tower gigabit when they only allocate 100mbps to it upstream, and then awarding $1.00 in damages to AT&T (without legal costs) so that both companies are forced to advertise more genuinely, eat their own legal costs for the fight, and so on. It would punish them both for being shitty and provide a foothold into future lawsuits over intentional underprovisioning for after-dinner radio hour. One can dream, sigh.
This has been a thing in the Netherlands for years. Ziggo has been advertising with terms like "Glasvezel-Kabel" (Fiber Optic - Cable) to indicate that the fiber goes up to a switch in the area, but then goes over coax cable to the residential buildings.
They got a lawsuit, and for some weird reason they even won it. I don't know it it really matters in the end, they lose some (technical) customers, they win some customers. But it feels like a nasty tactic anyway.
I think it's a common thing. In my country (Italy) they started first rolling out with FTTC (fiber to the cabinet), that is fiber till the nearest distribution cabinet and then from there normal phone line (copper twisted pair) to the user home. It was done to cover vast areas faster without requiring intervention, and for people living near the cabinet it did work really good (100-200Mbit/s, that coming from ADSL at 10-20 was a good improvement). If though you were unlucky to live far from the cabinet, speeds were not that great (compared to a good ADSL).
Now they are bringing FTTH that is fiber inside the home, that is both faster and cheaper for the operator to do because the network is passive (GPON) and doesn't require active equipment in the cabinets, and they plan to switch off the entire copper network in the upcoming years.
The most stupid part of this is that they know their coax networks are inferior. They started rolling out their own FttH in certain new construction for a reason.
Virgin media is the same in the UK. They call their service fibre but it’s coax. I’m not sure if they’ve been sued for it, but I think the classifications are normally “Fibre” (Fibre to the Cabinet ) and “Full Fibre” (Fibre to the Property). So in their favour.
Reminds me of the HD vs FHD stuff for TVs years back.
The advertising in this space is terrible. I constantly see ads for "gig wifi" and similar terms and have no idea what the actual internet connection type is.
It's not just advertising, people these days think they are buying "wifi" not internet access. I don't know if it's because of the push of ISPs into being your home network too, or if they got into pushing their wifi and routers so that they can "own" the whole experience but if you go ask the average person on the street what they buy from Xfinity the'll tell you wifi and not internet service
As much as it makes me cringe every single time someone says their wifi is down when its the internet connection, or their internet isn't good enough to stream from the Playstation downstairs to their phone upstairs, for the majority of people everything being one bundle is probably a net benefit because they just don't want to think about things at the level of granularity required.
What I would like to see is consumer hardware making better distinctions here, and providing more (actionable) detail on what the problem is. "Oops, there's been a problem" and messages of the like really don't help people in knowing things like running an ethernet cable upstairs would help them out.
I'd also absolutely love to see ISPs pushing a reset of the default SSID and passphrase on their all-in-one devices when people migrate from one provider to another, because its absolutely ridiculous the number of people who end up going round changing every device in their home from one impenetrable IspName-AE32C SSID to another when they could instead have changed two settings on the AP instead.
Yes, WiFi becoming synonymous with broadband does bug me (a little), but when you consider that on a mobile device you generally have “Mobile Data” or “WiFi” as your connectivity options it makes sense that your average person asks if you have “WiFi” rather “a broadband connection” (which in practice pretty much always includes a WiFi AP).
I could actually care less what most people call it or how they think about it, but the annoying part is when someone who does know the difference and cares about the actual connection and is going to do their own wifi setup, the ISPs treat you like an idiot or are themselves idiots when trying to talk to them
how many people have devices with an RJ45 jack, im not sure but it has been diminishing, take that along with the trend to put evrything on 'wifi", and there it is a general training to think internet comes off a wireless feed, to go along with the browser/app is the internet mentality.
I would guess they sell "wifi" because selling someone only a modem (or just the connection) is putting your company on a fast track to death by support costs. Get your techs to drill a single cable through the closest exterior wall, jam it into some all-in-one device, tell the user their new wifi creds, and leave. Easy peasy.
No, it is because to most people "wifi" is the internet. Home internet is "wifi", on-the-go internet is "5G". People with wired home internet devices have become the exception!
ISPs stopped using bare modems ages ago, and have universally switched to providing modem/router combos to home users - and those have included an integrated AP since pretty much the very start. They were marketed as "the internet" for about a decade and a half - until home desktop PCs all-but-died, the vast majority of the remainder switched to laptops, and the primary home internet devices became tablets and smartphones.
Bingo. And despite the fact that it’s for their convenience (lowers their support costs), and that these combo router things probably cost them $40 a unit at scale, they get to charge their subscribers like $14 a month forever as a rental fee for these things! Telecom math!
That sounds like a failure of consumer protection laws in your legislative area. In my country the ISP is legally required to let you use your own router, and they can not force you to pay a separate fee for the default ISP router you won't use. As a result, every single ISP has been providing the default router for free.
Somewhat recently they did start offering "wifi booster" add-on packages, but those are 100% optional and only prey on those too lazy to do a simple Google search.
Same here in the US. It’s always fine to use your own equipment, but surprisingly few customers know how. My ISP (Ziply Fiber) moved to providing the router for free last year, but that’s fairly rare. They also stopped offering promotional rates that expire after a year, since those also raise support costs, but most ISPs still use them.
Yes, same with a real fiber provider. Comcast will either give you a separate DOCSIS modem or they’ll let you put their router into bridge mode. Either way you can use your own router and WiFi access point.
Bridge mode is what I'm using now. I believe fiber is different as you can usually just spoof credentials, while DOCSIS includes fuckass cryptographic attestation.
This is just flat out false. I bought an Arris DOCSIS 3.1 modem a couple of months ago to replace the provided rental equipment that I didn't want to pay for, plugged it in, went to the Xfinity account page, typed in the new MAC address, went through their setup procedure, waited 5 minutes, and everything worked fine.
After doing that, I recycled the Motorola DOCSIS 3.0 modem I had, which I used to do the same thing at a different place 12+ years ago (though IIRC you had to call them back then).
I kind of feel like this happened by accident and we have companies like Linksys and Netgear to blame. 20 years ago (and I assume still now based on one recent experience) they put out such absolutely garbage hardware, which constantly needs to be rebooted, and which never provided good visibility for the common person to understand the difference between an outage and configuration error. So people eagerly adopted rental routers since they came with the promise that at least Comcast couldn’t just tell you to keep rebooting your computer when you called to report an apparent outage.
And just like that people went from seeing Wi-Fi as a product they were responsible for selecting and maintaining, to one that they expect to subscribe to as a service. And their kids were just raised in that world so Gen-Z definitely “pays their Wi-Fi bill” (eyeroll).
Comcast is the worst for this. Actual fiber companies are selling symmetric connections. Comcast still sells garbage like 1000gbps/30mbps. That is barely enough return bandwidth for traffic overhead.
You forgot the data cap meaning while you can burst you can't exceed ~20 Mbit sustained (I'm not clear if the caps are typically bidirectional). Meanwhile the local fiber company doesn't say a thing even if I sustain upwards of 800 Mbit 24/7 for months on end.
nope. nearly went over within the last couple months and had to switch to leeching off the neighbors til it reset (which counts against neither of our caps at the cost of much lower speeds)
The Comcast plan I has from Oct 2024 to Oct 2026 had a 1.2TB data cap. It was $35 per month for something like 200Mbps down and 10Mbps up. I exceeded it a couple times and was charged $10 for 50GB.
Good grief. Comcast currently charges me $70/month for 125Mbps down. Thankfully I'm switching over to T-mobile fiber soon. (1 gig symmetric for $55/month.)
IIRC the one an acquaintance currently has is capped at approximately 6 Tbit (on which I based the earlier math). I'm not sure what the terms for exceeding it are.
Was just forced to upgrade to a 50% more expensive "modern" gigabit Comcast cable plan from my existing "legacy" gigabit plan after they retroactively added data caps (with additional charges for overage maxing out at $100, which I would max out every billing period).
The one perk is that they are actually gracing me with higher-than-advertised download bandwidth (I think like 1.2 or 1.3 gigabit), which I've never gotten out of them before. Previously it was consistently around 70% of the advertised speed because of "network conditions and capacity", yet miraculously upgrading to a higher speed would get you more bandwidth (up to 70% of the higher advertised speed!).
The comparison charts for the services tend to be pretty dishonest, making ridiculous claims about what service you need to support basic vanilla levels of Internet activities. ("Want to send an email AND watch a Youtube video at the same time? You need our Ultra Super Fibernet Max Plus!")
And in most cases, the cheapest plan is enough for like 8 4K download streams at once, but uploading a small photo library to Google Drive takes hours.
The irony being that they're effectively wishing sites and services would become more inefficient so they can justify the amount of bandwidth they're selling.
On one hand, it's misleading. On the other, upstream and downstream capacities, quotas, and oversubscription ratios at different points in the network are what actually matter.
TMobile of all companies started offering fiber in my area. They ran fiber lines into the house. Real fiber too, I saw the install. 1000Mbps up/down. I hate Comcast & AT&T. TMobile for now can have all my money. So check your area if you are wanting to get one.
T-Mobile Fiber is almost always rebrands of local sub-carriers which T-Mobile either acquired or partner with - for example, in my area, they're the anchor tenant for Intrepid Fiber Networks. It's an interesting business model vs. a lot of the competitor models (either owned FTTP or fake-fiber like Comcast and old CenturyLink marketing)
AT&T and T-Mobile both installed fiber in my neighborhood this summer. AT&T started in the spring and still are not done. (Also their workers took out my cable internet with a shovel.)
T-Mobile had my street done in three weeks. They are offering twice the speed and half the price of my current plan through Comcast. I need to remember to call them tomrrow.
I am amazed you had two different fiber optic lines installed all the way to your home, in addition to coaxial cable. I only ever see fiber in new developments, and if there is buried coaxial cable in an old development, I have never seen it get fiber.
I remember reading about an (I think) european country where telco regulation meant that every home got two FTTH, and those were terminated in a central datacenter, meaning you could switch providers without changing equipment in your home. You would call them up, and they could switch it centrally. And you could have separate services on the separate fibers, for redundancy or comparison.
I'm struggling to search for the details now, but it sounded enlightened.
A relatively small company has been working on fiber in my little old post-industrial wasteland of a town in Ohio. (It's been a process for them -- their infrastructure is mostly underground.)
They finally got it into my neighborhood and I had it installed a couple of weeks ago. It's fiber all the way into the basement of the house where their ONT lives, right next to my router.
It's pretty great. Symmetric, gigabit (actually overprovisioned a bit at 1.2gbps or so). This opened the door to chase down some issues with queue management and NIC options for this OpenWRT build, but with that accomplished I can hammer it in both directions concurrently without latency spikes or SQM.
Previous to that, the only serious option here was Spectrum (in DOCSIS form since they're sleeping on their fiber rollouts). Spectrum worked quite well here for it was, but it was annoying having 500mbps of download and just 20mbps of upload. It's nice to get back to ISDN-esque symmetry like it's 1999 again.
You'd be amazed at how many small providers there are in the rural US that do decent fiber and wifi. In Ohio for example, off the top of my head: Paulding Putnam, TSC, Bascom. Some of them are 100 year old phone companies that pivoted to fiber, some are power companies, etc. And they have incredibly flat support structures eg after your ticket gets escalated it likely lands on the desk of the guy who programmed the OLT and the PE router. Sooo much nicer than Comcast and the other tier 1s.
Sadly their SEO budget is miniscule compared with those guys so they are often on page 2 of Google behind the wall of fake comparison sites.
They now offer DOCSIS 4.0 1 gigabit and 2 gigabit fully symmetric connections over cable lines. Obviously it's not fiber, but it really does meet the average person's understanding of what "fast fiber optic internet" is in every way.
Everyone at that scale has some fiber somewhere, even if only between switches in their DC, but that misleads buyers by implying that their own connection will involve fiber.
Yeah I've started seeing Xfinity's billboards for this around town (a growing Houston area suburb), and it's odd to me advertising this as some new development, since I've had AT&T fiber for 4 1/2 years.
"Powered by fiber" started with Cox, then Charter bought them and adopted it, and then Xfinity latched on and followed along with the "well, HFC is technically fiber!" advertising game.
What I'd really like to know is what the hell is up with the constant begging to sign up for the (Spectrum) mobile service. I've seen free lines for a year being given out like candy (or even wilder, free Internet for business customers that buy 4 lines) and it feels like it's all just to juice the customer into either device payment plans on new equipment or just to look good for the next 4 quarters of mobile subscriber growth and sneak one past the investors.
It seems to me like everyone’s trying to bundle everything. Amazon prime wants you to bundle One Medical. Walmart+ bundles Paramount Plus or Peacock and you can now add Sam’s Club to the bundle. T-Mobile wants to bundle every streaming service you have.
Once all of your subscriptions are tangled into two or three big messes, it is extremely unattractive to think about switching any of them. “if I switch my cell service to Verizon, then I’ll have to go screw around trying to undo the combined billing for my Netflix account.” or “if we switch to the new fiber ISP, Spectrum will cancel our cell phones because you have to be a cable subscriber. Gee, I hope that they don’t screw something up and end up losing our phone numbers! Maybe we should just not switch.”
Verizon certainly tried their best to get me to not bundle.
I had Verizon phone service for years because my wife's job got her some kind of discount.
When I bought my home, I was excited to finally get off of Xfinity and onto Verizon FIOS. The old owner had Verizon FIOS. All the equipment was in place. All Verizon had to do was flip a switch.
Nope. They demanded a $200 deposit.
For what, I asked? I said I've been your customer for 5+ years, you obviously know where I live, and the equipment's already here. They couldn't tell me. I asked... well, when do I get my deposit back? They said when I terminate service. I said well, I bought a house and I plan to be here for around 30 years. Until I die, if things go well. So practically speaking, I never get my $200 back, or if I'm lucky maybe around the time Halley's Comet returns.
So, I regretfully had to tell them to fuck off. Did not exactly bring me any happiness to resign myself to Xfinity instead.
What a terrible business decision on their part. They've already lost $30,000 alone thanks to their insistence on getting that $200 deposit. Plus a couple of hundred bucks on all the snail mail spam they've sent me over the years telling me how great FIOS is...
For future reference, you don't need their help to activate anything if the equipment is already there. You can self-service you activation just by going to this URL: https://activate.verizon.com/
They do it because it makes customers stickier, I think.
All telcos offer huge discounts to sign up, but those discounts aren't sustainably profitable. So prices usually rise afterwards... And then customers move.
They are betting that if you sign up to cable + mobile, you will be less likely to switch for the competing offer, and pay the higher long term price.
I'm in Spectrum territory and laugh at the "Fiber-powered Internet" line whenever
I see their ads. Technically, yes, it is fiber to the the nearest HFC node, but after that, good luck. There are supposedly a couple of locations where they'll give you actual fiber, but I've never seen one.
Anyway, I switched from cable to actual fiber a few years ago after a year of complaining to the HOA. I was getting massive packet loss and the upstream bandwidth would drop to single digit megabit speeds (they advertised 30.)
I used to have a local ISP in SF which was microwave. It was excellent. Best ISP I’ve ever had. I loved that it had symmetrical uploads, in fact, my upload was often way higher than my download, I assume just because the downstream channel was more congested. But it was much faster than any other options in both directions.
Its a matter of engineering. The problem isn't the technology, it's that microwave is really low hanging fruit that idiots can halfway engineer. Wireless is basically mud because of shitty sales guys throwing links up and then forcing customers to wear technical debt.
If you are talking about Seattle area, that's exactly what they did there.
To be fair, they did well by the original company, and in the region they officially refer to the service as "Google Fiber/Webpass" (or at least they did 3 years ago, before I left the area).
They definitely did that as well. In Austin, I had fiber-to-the-home and here in SF I had them as Microwave. The only FTTH I've had in SF is Sonic, though I've heard some people have AT&T Fiber.
Over a few weeks I watched an AT&T copper POTS box on the Delores street get hit by a truck, replaced, rewired with new copper, and the get an AT&T fiber decal slapped onto it.
I'd love to know if it's a real service anywhere in the city. Sonic is better but there coverage tends to be incomplete.
Sonic is good but they only serve areas with overhead power lines. They refuse to trench to lay fiber in places where utilities are buried.
I really wish the city would take control over getting fiber coverage everywhere. It's a little insane that in San Francisco, a city with a lot of very wealthy technology people, a large fraction of the city doesn't have fiber.
I heard a story of $famous_billionare_tech_exec calling up Sonic and asking them how much it would cost for him to pay them to lay fiber on his street (unfortunately don't remember what happened).
The city does take control of it. They’re the ones who blocked Sonic from microtrenching. I’m somewhat surprised as a SF resident that you believe that having the city government take control of something gets the thing done.
I have Sonic over in Alameda. $87 including taxes and state fees and all that for an uncapped 10Gbit connection with rock solid IPv6 and no prohibition against running home servers. I’ve never loved an ISP before.
Common sense says anything other than “FTTH” is not really fiber. Having some fiber in the network backbone (which is basically everything in 2026) doesn’t count as “fiber.”
Fiber is a pure and fully symmetrical signal in just your home. Coax is basically just RF over a wire and highly susceptible to all sorts of issues. That includes anyone in your neighborhood doing any of a long list of things including something as simple as having a cable not plugged into anything… which causes chaos on RF networks.
Coming from Comcast though, I suppose we shouldn’t be surprised at this nonsense.
I mean Comcast is "fibre powered" from the CMTS onwards.
And DOCSIS4.0 can offer higher speeds than AT&Ts older GPON FTTH.
But regardless it is extremely odd Comcast is spending so much to do a DOCSIS4.0 upgrade, given the costs between that and eg XGSPON are not huge - both require a lot of new equipment and fibre laid.
I am unaware of anyone but Comcast that is adopting DOCSIS4. Afiak all European cable companies are moving to XGS-PON.
I'm on a 2Gbps/2Gbps (but more like 2.5/2.5) DOCSIS4.0 plan in Seattle and as much as I hate to say it, it's been great.
But like, why would they go all the way to XGS-PON when they can use their existing HFC access network, maybe upgrade that to DAA/RPHY, combined with existing subscriber outside plant, and deliver an incremental improvement? As much as I'd love 10Gbps+ service, 2Gbps is already bananas, and there's nothing stopping them from replacing the last mile with glass eventually, either.
Well firstly, DOCSIS is becoming an increasingly niche technology, and niche technology in telecoms means expensive. There are probably 10,000x more (XGS)G-PON CPEs being manufactured than DOCSIS4.0 ones. I assume similar scale for PON headend equipment.
Secondly, PON basically has no powered equipment outside the 'exchange', which can serve 30k+ customers. DOCSIS requires loads of powered equipment, amplifiers, CMTS etc. This then costs money to power (and in high temps, cool) and more importantly breaks down more often. DOCSIS4.0 requires a lot of upgrades to the 'last mile' part so most telcos have decided to just go the whole way and replace with PON instead of doing all that work and getting none of the operational cost savings.
The issue is the faster you push DOCSIS the more it shows up any problems in your last mile setup.
You said it right there - we’re talking about Comcast here, so obviously if they could save even a nickel by using a technology that’s worse for the customer, they’ll choose that every time. It’s not like they have any competition to worry about! I’m aware AT&T has actual fiber in a few spots, but it’s so sparse compared to the whole footprint that Comcast DGAF if everyone with someone else’s fiber available drops them.
Oh that’s funny, I had the same gripe with Comcast - they kept saying they’d deliver fiber to the house, they’d install it, then it’d turn out to be coax/cable.
My roommates and I had them out to install, then canceled and refunded, like three times over the course of our ten years of living together. Each time, comcast and the installers lied about the service they were selling us.
> “Comcast should be required to restore to AT&T any and all profits earned as a result of its false and misleading advertising or provide AT&T with any other restitutionary relief the Court deems appropriate,” the lawsuit said. The lawsuit asked for a permanent injunction “requiring Comcast to cease describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as ‘Fiber-Powered.’”
The people Comcast is swindling with their false claims are their own customers, not AT&T. In what universe should this money be refunded to AT&T? It was never theirs! They are not entitled to other people's money!
If I sell something and someone wins customers away from me by means of false advertising and it's reasonably clear those customers would otherwise have patronized me then I have suffered proportional damages.
There are two basic attitudes to customers: people vs livestock.
In the former view customers are actual humans, your equals, who have rights and are as deserving of good treatment as you are.
In the latter, customers are your property. Once you have penned them in, you should be able to milk them as you please. They have no rights, and any noise they make to the contrary is so much mooing. Anybody milking customers that are rightfully yours isn't stealing from them. They're stealing from you.
AT&T also marketed their 4G network as "5GE" which was flagrant false advertising. I don't think corporate really cares, they just want to harm the other corporation. This is just the status quo of telecommunications and tech in America. It's all a scam and marketing, and if you complain, then you're fired.
I got frustrated with my spectrum docsis and decided to look for fiber providers in the area (One Wilshire is two blocks away, but no fiber around in residential buildings). Found Earthlink, went through hell trying to sign up with their voice llm bot, and then final ToS is something like this "just so you know, while plan called 'a gig', you probably going to get 400/20 at most".
Reminded me of a Spectrum guy crimping coaxial cable in front of and me telling me its fiber.
Retention guy tried to convince me that Spectrum was “mostly fiber”. Like yeah I’m sure there’s fiber in your network, let me know when it’s touching my house and I’ll switch back.
CenturyLink carpetbombed my neighborhood with comments on how we might have seen their vans and we have fiber.
I didn’t think so. Checked online, not within 50 miles. Called because why not, leaflet, door to door. Nope.
Then “why do you need gigabit? Perhaps you’re paying for sport you don’t need?” (They only offered 24mbps).
No dude, sorry, not paying ten buck less for fifty times less speed (and I work from home in an industry that uses a good amount of bandwidth, my partner also works from home part time, stepdaughter loves her 4K.
Yes, still a lot of headroom, including game and media download. But hah “you probably couldn’t tell the difference most of the time”?
lol. The only company lazier than Comcast at building FTTP[1] is throwing stones at them. Hilarious!
AT&T barely showed up with fiber outside of big buildings when I lived in SF, topping out with 20Mb UVerse as recently as 2017. Now, I live in another area in their footprint and they just aren’t even playing. If you put my address in, in a high-priced suburb, they suggest cellular internet.
I’d still be happy to see any big telecom ISP lose a lawsuit like this, because they’re all scum.
[1] edit: I should’ve said “building out infrastructure” since Comcast to be fair doesn’t build any FTTP to speak of, whereas AT&T builds a tiny bit. But if the question is “percentage of your footprint that can access a speed of 1Gbps over the infrastructure you’ve laid to their house” Comcast wins by a (last) mile.
I was still thinking about this, and went looking for more - the FCC's broadband maps[0] claims that AT&T FTTP covers ~18% of units. So, definitely nowhere near universal, but I guess I'd count that as more than "a tiny bit".
For what it’s worth, my mid-sized city in the Midwest has quite a bit of AT&T FTTP and they are expanding at a reasonable pace. I would estimate they cover 80% of the neighborhoods around me (3 years ago, they covered 0%). This is all area previously only serviced by Spectrum coax (asymmetrical DOCSIS).
When I moved into my current address, the property manager told me I had two options for my ISP: Spectrum or AT&T. Of course as soon as I select AT&T I get a call from one of their sales people telling me "no lol, we aren't actually available there"
There's not really consumer-available stuff, but there is expensive purpose built stuff you can buy for thousands of dollars to send tiny amounts of power.
Cable in my country had the advantage that it was already in every home- it was installed all the way back in the 80s to replace the infamous antennas.
But no matter what you do it is ancient tech that can't beat fiber so dig dig dig!
"Fiber-powered" reminds me of when you see an inverter advertised as "modified sine wave." Or something in the dairy case at the grocery store labeled "cheese food product."
Both of these companies are doing the same thing. Yes, obviously Comcast is using the word "fiber" to try to piggy-back on the layman's shallow understanding of that word as "fancy Internet thing".
But so is AT&T. The practical limits of optical and DOCSIS are basically equivalent to a home user, but AT&T pitches their product as "fiber" to dazzle the uneducated customer.
In an ideal world, they'd compete just on latency, throughput, and reliability.
But AT&T actually runs fiber so I'm not following you here. I have AT&T and it's a real fiber optic cable they ran from the pole into my house. What are you getting at? Meanwhile, Comcast does, in fact, claim they are fiber even though they run coax cable.
I have 'cable', but it's actually fiber to my house and there is a power injector in my closet that runs power over the 30' of coax I have to run a coax to fiber converter of some kind. This isn't Comcast, but I suspect lots of new builds have odd things like this. Most people would have no clue what's running to the side of their house.
That's not particularly odd - FTTH with MoCA (ie coax) from the ONT to the vendor supplied router was standard at one point. However I believe most ISPs that offer fiber have moved to an ONT that integrates the router at this point due to throughput requirements as many of them now offer routine home service in excess of 5 Gbit.
Meanwhile comcast largely does not do FTTH, at least where I'm at. (They do have fiber to a box a few blocks down the street in many neighborhoods here though.)
In my area Comcast is only doing fiber for new multi-family construction.
Brand new construction is still getting regular coax even if the new neighborhood is getting its own fiber run and node.
I do not understand why; seems like anything we're going to do to get more bandwidth out of shared coax is going to be expensive? Seems like we have a lot more room in the optical space?
Comcast has tons of fiber just like their competitors. They're using "Hybrid Fiber Coax" plant, where only the last 100m or so is coax. Walk around the neighborhood and you'll see the fiber (orange sleeves on the cable and slack coils).
> But AT&T actually runs fiber so I'm not following you here.
Certainly, at&t has been running fiber for the better part of a century.
That said, they were selling u-verse DSL as 'fiber' back when I was in their territory; they did bring fttp to my premesis eventually, but only after Google announced they were building out (Google didn't, of course).
The nutritional values of potatoes and rice are basically equivalent to the average eater. Would it be okay if a "sushi" restaurant stuffed yours with mashed potato instead of rice?
The problem is that Comcast is lying. They are marketing one product (fiber) and delivering another (DOCSIS). That's fraud.
This lawsuit would not exist if Comcast had stuck to a marketing term such as "fiber-like speeds". But they got too greedy, and ended up misleading the consumer.
Fiber is so much better than cable in an emergency. The equipment consumes significantly less power and is likely to stay up longer during a power outage. You get way more customers on each battery / generator.
I had an FTTH provider with 100% of their network on natural gas standby generators. Went through a week long power outage without losing a single packet. You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power. There are homes with larger generators than this. Docsis 4 would put you somewhere around half a megawatt.
> You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power. There are homes with larger generators than this.
There are what? I can't imagine what a single-family home would do with 50kW of power.
On an ongoing basis, no, but some appliances (especially air conditioning) have significant inrush current. Off grid systems have to be designed to either do without those or be able to handle them, even if for just 200ms. TBH I'm not familiar with gas/propane generators, but if their nameplate capacities significantly oversell their ability to handle sudden inrush currents without losing a lot of voltage then I could see how you could end up with a home with a bigger generator. I'm much more familiar with battery inverter setups, which suffer the same problem but at least if they say then can do split phase at 12kW if you actually ask it for 12kW at 240v you're generally going to get 240v.
Though installing a soft start goes a long way to helping reduce that need, regardless of which technology is used.
> There are what? I can't imagine what a single-family home would do with 50kW of power.
In US/CA your feed is 240V (L1-L2-N) and a 200A service is standard on homes built in the last ~20 years: 240V*200A = 48000W (48kW).
Holy moly! Here in Italy, the average residential power supply is around 3.3 kW. It might be a bit higher nowadays, but now I understand why in movies you always see the mad scientist working in the basement surrounded by heavy equipment!
You will generally not use anywhere near that much simultaneously. Cooking ranges are wired with 50A nowadays, but you'd have to use all (four) elements at 100% as well as be (pre-)heating the oven at the same time to even get close to that.
Clothes dryers are usually 30A, and external AC units are in the 30A range as well for a medium unit.
You'd be having to do a lot of things all at once to even get close to 100A, never mind 200A.
Agree - I have 200 amp service, but by far the largest spike on the load graphs (15 minute average) is the car charger at 32 amps.
There are induction ranges that can saturate the circuit without all burners being on. The software is responsible for handling power distribution to accommodate.
and there are others that come with battery packs that you install underneath them in order to be able to max out all of the "burners" simultaneously without overloading the circuit.
That is not even single 16A fuse? My Finnish flat has 3x25A. And that is not with sauna or anything...
This isn't even two circuits in North America.
Blowing your house breaker in the morning cause someone turned on a hair dryer while someone else was making coffee sound nuts.
We have breakers on every individual circuit. You won't blow the whole house by running a coffee maker and a hairdryer at the same time, but you will blow that single circuit if you run them both on it simultaneously.
A whole house breaker is 100, 150, now 200A minimum in new builds for single family homes. My 1br rental apartment from the 90s has 100A service.
Just because we only have one main circuit coming into the house doesn't mean you have to be careful not to run the vacuum and the stove at the same time...
I couldn't imagine only having 3.3kW for a normal home. A normal electric oven/stove combo here can easily use 10kW+ of peak power, assuming you're using four burners and the oven. And you haven't even turned on a blender or used any hot water yet.
During the heat wave over the summer my AC was using about 4kW of power on its own, and that's just the compressor outside.
Lots of Brits will use 3kW just heating their tea.
Yep, that's exactly how many Italian households operate.
The unwritten rule is: if someone is using the hairdryer, nobody touches the oven, washing machine, or vacuum cleaner.
Things are getting better with more efficient appliances and higher-capacity contracts, but for a long time "What can I turn on without tripping the breaker?" was a daily consideration.
Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me. That's more than the entire standard power allowance of many Italian homes!
> Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me.
That's often on start-up. I'm in an older Canadian house with 'only' a 100A service, and when the external AC unit kicks on there's often a flicker to lights. (Often with vacuum too.)
It might be a good idea for me to install a soft start device (which would also probably help with unit longevity):
* https://www.microair.net/collections/easystart-soft-starters
You can find various before/after videos about them being installed and the much lower in-rush current.
Nah, ~16-18A @ 240V running for a 5-ton rated AC unit when its hot out were the measurements I took when servicing it this summer before the heat really hit. The nameplate actually rates the unit for ~27 RLA (Rated Load Amps) with an LRA (Locked Rotor Amps) at about 140A.
Its usually pretty common to hit anywhere between 60-80% RLA during a normal summer day.
> Reading that your AC alone draws 4 kW is wild to me. That's more than the entire standard power allowance of many Italian homes!
Questo perché hanno case mal isolate, troppo grandi e usano condizionatori a tecnologia obsoleta, senza inverter, che possono solo funzionare a 100% (e se gli va bene hanno un secondo stage a 50%).
Oh no, la mia casa è troppo grande? Che problema terribile. Magari potessi vivere in una scatola da scarpe.
Lots of time of the yeary system runs almost exclusively it's second stage. An inverter unit wouldn't do much for me but increase my upfrontcosts considerably while reducing reliability. The way the climate is here, a two stage unit is plenty of variability. It doesn't take long for the heat to set in. You go from not needing any AC to wanting to crank it pretty quick. There's a bit of efficiency gains with an inverter unit, but it'll take most of the life of the unit to offset the cost difference with the price of electricity here.
I have a large woodworking and metalworking shop behind my single family home.
I have a transformer that serves only my shop :)
I use 800 amps of single phase inverted into 200 amps of 480v 3 phase (the rest of the single phase is for the house and apartment above the shop)
I have 200kwh of battery as well.
This is definitely on the extreme side, but most woodworkers (and metalworkers) i know use 50kw total easily within their single family home garages. Once you get past portable tools, they really don't make tools with less than a 5hp motor because it would be more expensive and annoying.
ok but how much you actually use ? Even if every tool is 10kW (which would be pretty fucking powerful), you're using maybe that, few kW for dust extractor and waht else ?
Unless you have employees (and at that point, not really a house but business), how ?
If you have electric cars and multiple air conditioners it adds up fast.
You might be surprised by what a successful career salesman will upsell.
I certainly would not be. What's the saying about a fool and their money?
You and the other replyer are missing the context. Supporting data connections to 100k households, not the households themselves!
No. They are just talking about the 50kw home generations mentioned by the upstream comment.
Not a normal single-family home, maybe a complex with 20+ appartements, or a villa with multiple hot swimming pools, server room, plus attached housekeeper appartments...
> I can't imagine what a single-family home would do with 50kW of power.
Your average European SFH has anything from 25-50 kW of heating power for heating and warm water plus 22 kW of electrical load (3x32A @ 230V). Easy enough to do with natural gas or oil, but if you want to switch towards electricity as energy source with all the wars going on... you now need a whole lot of electrical generation capability to survive an outage in the winter, even with heat pumps.
(Don't get me started on the French, these fools need so many NPPs because they run straight resistive electrical heaters, what a waste compared to heat pumps)
25-50 kW of heating power is still massive. A somewhat decently insulated house can do with half of that.
I heat my house + provide hot water with a heat pump of 6 kW output. I do everything with electricity; before we had an EV and solar panels my yearly electricity consumption was something like 3400 kWh. Granted, that is with a very well insulated house and definitely below average but still, average houses here don't need anywhere close to 50 kW. You can't even get such a connection to the grid as a residential user; a standard connection is ~16kW although you can request a bit more.
> A somewhat decently insulated house can do with half of that.
Yeah but most homes in Germany (or, while we're at it, in France) aren't. As a result, we pay through our nose for oil and gas, and the French have to cross-fund EdF with its NPP boondoggles that explode in budget and come decades late.
> You can't even get such a connection to the grid as a residential user; a standard connection is ~16kW although you can request a bit more.
Huh what? 16 kW is about 3x20 amps, that's rare to see even for apartments these days. Standard I've seen in Bavaria for apartments is 3x25, SFH is 3x40 amps, some 3x50, and if it's a former farm site, 63, 80 or even 100 amps.
That is half a watt per connection? It sounds low to me. Considering with all other power needed for the gear. Fiber is efficient but it still sounds very low.
These are passive optical networks. You can put something like 64 subscribers on a single 5 watt port.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_optical_network
Most of AT&T's new residential fiber construction these days is passive. It also means you share a time-multiplexed connection with your neighbors just like the coax systems. You get periods of congestion.
> You can support something like 100k households with well under 50kW of power
I feel like there's something wrong here; you're three orders of magnitude off. Many typical household appliances easily cross multiple kilowatts. For some scale: running a kettle, a washing machine at max temperature, a dishwasher, a microwave, a high-end gaming PC, and a conventional oven, all simultaneously, approaches a power draw of about 25 kW.
100k fibre connections.
Aha. Thanks.
> For some scale: running a kettle, a washing machine at max temperature, a dishwasher, a microwave, a high-end gaming PC, and a conventional oven, all simultaneously, approaches a power draw of about 25 kW.
2.5 + 2.5 + 2.5 + 1 + maybe 3kW. How you got 25kW out of 11.5kW ?
While Comcast has deployed plenty of fiber throughout the US, its cable Internet service makes the final connection to homes with coaxial cable. This results in upload speeds being far slower than download speeds. In contrast, fiber-to-the-home service can provide symmetrical upload and download speeds.
You can get symmetric DOCSIS, and apparently Comcast do offer that service[1]. Likewise, FTTH can be asymmetric if they set the traffic shaping that way. IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability. As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.
In fact, anecdotes from a few people I know have been that service interruptions actually increased after they upgraded to FTTH from DOCSIS.
[1] https://corporate.comcast.com/press/releases/comcast-multi-g...
> As long as it terminates in WiFi or a standard Ethernet connector and passes IP traffic at the rate I paid for, I personally don't care what the physical infrastructure beyond the demarc is.
I get that attitude, but coax connections are fragile in a way that fiber is not. Water infiltration, bad crimping jobs, unterminated ends in the neighbor's house all cause signal degradation that is extremely time and labor intensive to identify and fix.
Cable is an excellent solution for distributing broadcast analog radio signals over a private line cheaply and efficiently, but two-way digital signals over the same medium aren't as robust as their fiber-based counterpart.
ISP outages are one thing, but if you ever experience service degradation—and not a full outage, but tear-your-hair-out crap like "my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern"—and it ends up being some particularly coax-flavored problem, you'll understand what I'm talking about.
my internet goes down for 15 seconds once every 16 hours with no discernible pattern
Actually that's exactly the type of complaints I've heard from those who upgraded to FTTH. My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper, and installation and testing requires significantly more expensive equipment, although it is cheaper for longer distances and theoretically capable of higher bandwidth (but the transceivers on each end are also a significant part of the cost.)
Upgrading to fiber was the best thing I've ever done in terms of internet service. I've never heard of what you claimed. Myself and everyone I know, anecdotally, have had FAR better service reliability with fiber. Also, having massive upload capacity papers over other failings elsewhere in your tech stack, like a router that doesn't know how to properly queue. Well, throw a ton of bandwidth at it and there's no big queue backing up anyway.
The only time fiber has gone out for me, including power outages that impacted my home, was if a neighbor or another ISP was digging and cut my line. That said, this happened with coax, and would be a problem with anything except a WISP or Starlink.
Indeed, if I move and fiber isn't available but cable is, I'll probably just go Starlink. I'd rather deal with that variability than ghost-in-the-machine coax craziness.
The real life rates of these things happening to people is low. We humans remember these events precisely because they are not common. This is why each of you is adamant different solutions are better.
As for satellite I think I’d rather just not have internet than go that route. Maybe read more.
Is it possible you need to disclose some conflicts of interest here?
Fiber doesn't have the noise or attenuation issues that coax does. Having worked in the industry and monitored plant, things like daily temps, proximity to radio transmitters, water in the soil can all cause signal to noise issues with coax.
Also, coax is much more vulnerable to a bad modem on the line causing noise.
> My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper
Source? I thought fibre works or it doesn’t.
Fiber can snap very easily where's copper does not have this problem. Most of the time this is something only technicians could cause to begin with though.
I find it wild that apparently a lot of the US installs fiber by just direct burying in people’s lawns by a few inches (or less).
I’ve had either aerial or (more often) conduit everywhere I e lived.
Depends but most of time, it's aerial if poles exist, then it's buried in lawns for last mile.
Yeah, seems crazy to me, but I guess people are ok with that.
"down for 15 seconds every X hours" sounds like PPP reauth forced by the ISP.
In other words, a software thing.
Kind of a big wat to this whole post. I've never, ever heard, or experienced myself or with clients, anyone across three continents having anything less then a rock solid experience with FTTH. Only trouble has always been getting it installed in the first place.
>My understanding is that fiber is a lot more fragile than copper
How did you reach that understanding? It's the opposite, fiber is a lot tougher particularly at high speeds. For outdoors I use stuff with a steel helix armor and then kevlar, you can direct bury it a few inches and drive a truck or tractor over it no problem. It's immune to electrical interference, you don't have to worry about surges to different ground potentials, water is no issue. People sometimes talk about bend radius but it's something like 10x diameter installed and 20x under tension (pulling) which is trivial given how thin fiber is. And high performance copper has a bend radius too, which isn't as high a multiple but simultaneous copper is a lot thicker.
>and installation and testing requires significantly more expensive equipment
On the installation side no, not sure what you'd be thinking of there. Pulling cable is pulling cable. On the testing side, sorta? A hobbyist who is just willing to redo things while they're learning can get away with cheap stuff, just like with ethernet. I guess it's true higher end testing equipment (like Fluke) ramps up faster than ethernet, higher floor, but the most serious kit is really expensive for both, and simultaneously is a fixed cost that is clearly meant for contracts that will pay it. Anyone spending $15k on a DSX ethernet kit is doing government or enterprise contracts or something where the cost will amortize out, same as with fiber.
The only area where there's a clear (but still one time) cost/irritation difference is if a cable is broken and needs to be spliced. But this too correlates with "if you're big enough to actually need to care the cost gets amortized".
>although it is cheaper for longer distances
Can't do long distances with high performance copper at all, setting aside cheaper (and yes copper has skyrocketed in price).
>and theoretically capable of higher bandwidth
Uh, "theoretically"? Fiber is much, much higher bandwidth, no theory about it.
>(but the transceivers on each end are also a significant part of the cost.)
A 20km class GPON (1G) transceiver new, no bulk pricing, starts around $40, and an XGPON (10G) around $50. SFP+ ones are less. Yes if you get into 100-800 Gbps class transceiver cost goes way up, but so does all the equipment one would use for that (100G is probably going to be at least $250/port last I checked) even before touching on whatever is actually making use of such a network. Transceiver cost would not be a significant part of overall project cost.
Or "after every major rain speed drops to a fraction of the advertised speed and Youtube starts to buffer"
> IMHO the only things that matter to the average user about an Internet connection are bandwidth, volume, and availability.
Latency, quality of networking gear, the experience of connecting devices, customer service, price of bundled services etc.
There is a lot that matters. As someone who’s worked in networking gear and both ISPs and customers, those who just want a connection and manage the rest are a minuscule percentage.
Almost everyone who buys a connection wants it to work perfect always and when not they want a simple step to fix it (like a reboot). Achieving this has a lot of moving parts.
If bandwidth, latency and availability is fine the customer service is irrelevant.
Bad gear can spoil it but I don't think that's all that hard to do.
To add more context: fiber allows for complete remote configuration and management. While docsis does have a lot of control it’s an old technology with lot less available for remote monitoring and configuration.
With fiber you can even change the WiFi password without ever having to connect to the WiFi. Yes that’s worse for privacy and security but it’s going to save you in hundreds of thousands of dollars in customer service calls.
This is TR-069 provisioning right? Pretty much all types of CPE support it, Fiber, DSL, DOCSIS. There's nothing specifically about fiber that makes it better or worse for remote provisioning, except maybe the hardware tends to be a lot newer.
Yes TR-069 and now omci with fiber. I’m not saying it’s not possible with docsis. Just that everything new with fiber is just more sensible and even affordable. Fiber is actually quite cheap in developing countries like India.
Hell, not even TR-069. It was fun to slide around the admin network of the ISP I was taking calls for and remote into the back end of cable (and DSL!) modems with the silly password of the day and just read out people's Wi-Fi passwords at them because they forgot it.
Pepperidge Farm remembers signing in as root/12345 to a looot of Comtrend ADSL crap, too.
Telnet to provision static IPs on business class modems. :D
I don't understand this point of distinction for a couple of different reasons:
I've remotely configured wifi services within end-user DOCSIS equipment; doing this was part of my job, and was part of a service that customers paid for
My FTTH connection at home terminates in a pretty dumb little box that does not have any wifi capabilities at all, and this box sits on the Internet-facing side of my firewall
Docsis is patches upon upgrades.
That's horrifying. No wonder people are so obsessive about swapping out their ISP-provided fiber modems -- even moreso than they were about DOCSIS.
DOCSIS cable modems weren't also routers or wireless access points until recently. All of the common fiber ONTs can be configured as such and typically are.
Today, you can buy a DOCSIS cable modem on Amazon with no router functionality and use it with any provider. You cannot select or provide a fiber ONT, use an SFP instead, etc. with any major residential provider.
Yes you can use your own SPF PON stick. I do it on ATT. More info: https://pon.wiki/
As far as I know you cannot do so on Verizon, YMMV.
News to me, great to know.
> DOCSIS cable modems weren't also routers or wireless access points until recently.
The Motorola SURFboard SBG900 was released in 2003 and had B/G WiFi built-in. My own personal experiences in a few different markets and cable companies, they nearly all offered all-in-one modem/router/wifi gateways since I dunno, at least 2005-2006 or so. You could also get just a modem.
While you are correct that you can get symmetric on assymetric services on both (essentially that was possible before as well, if you went for e.g 100Mbit), docsis 4.0 itself is still asymmetric due to spectrum allocation, tx power, noise ... I think theoretically you can get 6/10G up/down. Does that matter right now? Probably not if you don't have noisy neighbors, however the long term upgrade path is very different and there are other disadvantages like latency, jitter, reliability... All of which people associate to be better with fiber, hence Comcasts advertises as fiber powered
Service. What I most value from my service provider is that I can get answers from them without being treated like a baby.
Last time I called my ISP (last year? the year before? I don't remember) I was wondering when I would get service back. The street had exploded, underground power cable threw a tantrum and tore a big hole in the road, the grid company come out and fixed that but then of course my Internet didn't come back once the lights did.
The person who answered my call:
+ Did not waste my time asking that I restart laptops, routers, etc. the diagnostic lights on the router indicate No signal => not a problem I can fix by rebooting things.
+ Without needing me to re-specify where I live went straight to the identified problem (DSLAM offline) and to the fault report (to last mile provider for a failed DSLAM) and told me that in their experience I should expect a fix on Sunday (it was Friday evening). Which is what happened.
I had an outage of my DOCSIS cable this morning. About 15 minutes after it went out I received a text from the provider that there was a known outage, with an ETA for a fix, and one for the next message to expect. It ended up coming back on after 45 minutes, but this was a decent experience.
I suspect the asymmetry is designed to prevent people from broadcasting/streaming. I bet it works about 98% of the time but hiccups when other people use it. Probably just enough to upsell you to commercial service. It also prevents people from having high traffic websites, again so they can sell you the solution. (I know cloudflare exists, but these systems were designed 20+ years ago)
You are overthinking this. DOCSIS 1.0 had asymmetric speeds baked into the standard in part because when it was designed the cable TV industry was beginning to switch to IPTV systems. Cable TV is highly asymmetric and so the networks were set up for asymmetric traffic patterns anyway; it made perfect sense to do the same for DOCSIS. At the time cable Internet service was competing with dialup ISPs, and nobody was hosting anything on a dialup connection so I doubt anyone was thinking about that.
The biggest motivation for modern cable ISPs to provision more upstream capacity for residential users was COVID. A lot of residential users were suddenly using Zoom/etc. all day long, and upstream throughput was a problem.
I've had to deal with way too many noisy neighbors on coax to ever want to deal with that again. Too many times of unexplainable drops in signal quality that can never be replicated in the 10 minute window when a tech shows up days later. You just realistically don't get that with almost all residential fiber deployments.
I never want to have to deal with copper networking I can't completely control.
Comcast is indeed starting to offer symmetric DOCSIS. I recently saw my upload speed move from a completely useless 35 Mbps to a more reasonable 2350 Mbps. The Comcast tech really did not want to upgrade my DOCSIS 3.1 modem to a DOCSIS 4.0 modem, which was required for upload speeds to exceed 400 Mbps, but they thankfully did. The previous modem didn't even support Wi-Fi 7. (Though I now thankfully use this one in bridge mode. What a relief -- I hope to never touch their mandatory fucking mobile app ever again.)
Note that I had to make an FCC false advertising complaint earlier this year before they would upgrade my area. You should try it, the executive who contacted me was surprisingly willing to drill into the control structures to figure out what was going on.
Symmetric docsis is pretty awesome though… still dealing with asymmetric for pay per view reasons elsewhere!
Cabel/docsis have a bad rep so that's the reason they are lying.
Back in the days of rolling out U-Verse (their FTTN service), AT&T's advertising used exactly the same strategy of weasel-words to say "fiber" without making an actionable implication that it was fiber from A to Z. Phrases like "fiber rich network" and "U-Verse uses fiber optic technology."
Just a few years ago during the industry-wide upgrades to 5G, AT&T branded their 4G service as "5G E (5G Evolution)"
They are terribly slimy.
https://www.pbs.org/newshour/economy/att-to-drop-misleading-...
Apple and Google should have refused to play along and just continued to display the LTE indicator.
Money talks
I also got Cox's "fiber" and was really confused when they told me to reuse my DOCSIS modem. Didn't get symmetric speeds, but at least upload was a lot better than before.
I came here to say the same thing, I remember getting an ad for "U-Verse" and being like "omg fiber???" and then did their online check to see that it was basically DSL.
Yeah Uverse is some weird television bundle shit they're doing away with now.
This would make a lovely amicus curiae, if someone were to raise such, on Comcast’s behalf. Not that I think it’s worth the time — they can both rot as far as I’m concerned — but if you want to see AT&T get a bit of fuck around find out energy in a federal lawsuit, a judge would probably quite value an expert opinion prepared to federal court standards. I could very well see them ruling that the lowest-provisioned segment of delivery between the CO and the terminal must be the transport method and capacity advertised, so that they can’t just run FTTH from an ISDN line or call a radio tower gigabit when they only allocate 100mbps to it upstream, and then awarding $1.00 in damages to AT&T (without legal costs) so that both companies are forced to advertise more genuinely, eat their own legal costs for the fight, and so on. It would punish them both for being shitty and provide a foothold into future lawsuits over intentional underprovisioning for after-dinner radio hour. One can dream, sigh.
This has been a thing in the Netherlands for years. Ziggo has been advertising with terms like "Glasvezel-Kabel" (Fiber Optic - Cable) to indicate that the fiber goes up to a switch in the area, but then goes over coax cable to the residential buildings.
They got a lawsuit, and for some weird reason they even won it. I don't know it it really matters in the end, they lose some (technical) customers, they win some customers. But it feels like a nasty tactic anyway.
Dutch: https://www.rechtspraak.nl/organisatie-en-contact/organisati...
I think it's a common thing. In my country (Italy) they started first rolling out with FTTC (fiber to the cabinet), that is fiber till the nearest distribution cabinet and then from there normal phone line (copper twisted pair) to the user home. It was done to cover vast areas faster without requiring intervention, and for people living near the cabinet it did work really good (100-200Mbit/s, that coming from ADSL at 10-20 was a good improvement). If though you were unlucky to live far from the cabinet, speeds were not that great (compared to a good ADSL).
Now they are bringing FTTH that is fiber inside the home, that is both faster and cheaper for the operator to do because the network is passive (GPON) and doesn't require active equipment in the cabinets, and they plan to switch off the entire copper network in the upcoming years.
But they already called FTTC "Fiber" so now that they are bringing FTTH the average peaple wonder: "But I have fiber already, what is this all about?"
The most stupid part of this is that they know their coax networks are inferior. They started rolling out their own FttH in certain new construction for a reason.
Virgin media is the same in the UK. They call their service fibre but it’s coax. I’m not sure if they’ve been sued for it, but I think the classifications are normally “Fibre” (Fibre to the Cabinet ) and “Full Fibre” (Fibre to the Property). So in their favour.
Reminds me of the HD vs FHD stuff for TVs years back.
The Virgin cables outside my building are not even coax, just twisted pair.
The advertising in this space is terrible. I constantly see ads for "gig wifi" and similar terms and have no idea what the actual internet connection type is.
It's not just advertising, people these days think they are buying "wifi" not internet access. I don't know if it's because of the push of ISPs into being your home network too, or if they got into pushing their wifi and routers so that they can "own" the whole experience but if you go ask the average person on the street what they buy from Xfinity the'll tell you wifi and not internet service
As much as it makes me cringe every single time someone says their wifi is down when its the internet connection, or their internet isn't good enough to stream from the Playstation downstairs to their phone upstairs, for the majority of people everything being one bundle is probably a net benefit because they just don't want to think about things at the level of granularity required.
What I would like to see is consumer hardware making better distinctions here, and providing more (actionable) detail on what the problem is. "Oops, there's been a problem" and messages of the like really don't help people in knowing things like running an ethernet cable upstairs would help them out.
I'd also absolutely love to see ISPs pushing a reset of the default SSID and passphrase on their all-in-one devices when people migrate from one provider to another, because its absolutely ridiculous the number of people who end up going round changing every device in their home from one impenetrable IspName-AE32C SSID to another when they could instead have changed two settings on the AP instead.
Yes, WiFi becoming synonymous with broadband does bug me (a little), but when you consider that on a mobile device you generally have “Mobile Data” or “WiFi” as your connectivity options it makes sense that your average person asks if you have “WiFi” rather “a broadband connection” (which in practice pretty much always includes a WiFi AP).
I could actually care less what most people call it or how they think about it, but the annoying part is when someone who does know the difference and cares about the actual connection and is going to do their own wifi setup, the ISPs treat you like an idiot or are themselves idiots when trying to talk to them
how many people have devices with an RJ45 jack, im not sure but it has been diminishing, take that along with the trend to put evrything on 'wifi", and there it is a general training to think internet comes off a wireless feed, to go along with the browser/app is the internet mentality.
I would guess they sell "wifi" because selling someone only a modem (or just the connection) is putting your company on a fast track to death by support costs. Get your techs to drill a single cable through the closest exterior wall, jam it into some all-in-one device, tell the user their new wifi creds, and leave. Easy peasy.
No, it is because to most people "wifi" is the internet. Home internet is "wifi", on-the-go internet is "5G". People with wired home internet devices have become the exception!
ISPs stopped using bare modems ages ago, and have universally switched to providing modem/router combos to home users - and those have included an integrated AP since pretty much the very start. They were marketed as "the internet" for about a decade and a half - until home desktop PCs all-but-died, the vast majority of the remainder switched to laptops, and the primary home internet devices became tablets and smartphones.
> ISPs stopped using bare modems ages ago
Not true for my major-US-market ISP. I get a modern for free and they want $10/month to lease me a WiFi router.
On-the-go internet isn't even "5G", it's "data" or "signal"
Bingo. And despite the fact that it’s for their convenience (lowers their support costs), and that these combo router things probably cost them $40 a unit at scale, they get to charge their subscribers like $14 a month forever as a rental fee for these things! Telecom math!
That sounds like a failure of consumer protection laws in your legislative area. In my country the ISP is legally required to let you use your own router, and they can not force you to pay a separate fee for the default ISP router you won't use. As a result, every single ISP has been providing the default router for free.
Somewhat recently they did start offering "wifi booster" add-on packages, but those are 100% optional and only prey on those too lazy to do a simple Google search.
Same here in the US. It’s always fine to use your own equipment, but surprisingly few customers know how. My ISP (Ziply Fiber) moved to providing the router for free last year, but that’s fairly rare. They also stopped offering promotional rates that expire after a year, since those also raise support costs, but most ISPs still use them.
AT&T requires you to use their awful "gateway" (ONT & router combo), and while there are bypasses it's a pain in the neck
Comcast will cut your line if they detect DOCSIS equipment that isn't their own. Though, that's modems and not routers.
I've been using my own cable modems on Comcast for well over a decade.
This isn't true, Comcast is legally required by the FCC to allow you to use your own modem
Yes, same with a real fiber provider. Comcast will either give you a separate DOCSIS modem or they’ll let you put their router into bridge mode. Either way you can use your own router and WiFi access point.
Bridge mode is what I'm using now. I believe fiber is different as you can usually just spoof credentials, while DOCSIS includes fuckass cryptographic attestation.
This is just flat out false. I bought an Arris DOCSIS 3.1 modem a couple of months ago to replace the provided rental equipment that I didn't want to pay for, plugged it in, went to the Xfinity account page, typed in the new MAC address, went through their setup procedure, waited 5 minutes, and everything worked fine.
After doing that, I recycled the Motorola DOCSIS 3.0 modem I had, which I used to do the same thing at a different place 12+ years ago (though IIRC you had to call them back then).
I kind of feel like this happened by accident and we have companies like Linksys and Netgear to blame. 20 years ago (and I assume still now based on one recent experience) they put out such absolutely garbage hardware, which constantly needs to be rebooted, and which never provided good visibility for the common person to understand the difference between an outage and configuration error. So people eagerly adopted rental routers since they came with the promise that at least Comcast couldn’t just tell you to keep rebooting your computer when you called to report an apparent outage.
And just like that people went from seeing Wi-Fi as a product they were responsible for selecting and maintaining, to one that they expect to subscribe to as a service. And their kids were just raised in that world so Gen-Z definitely “pays their Wi-Fi bill” (eyeroll).
They should be advertising numerical up/down bandwidths, volumes, and prices.
Or they say it's a gig, but it's actually only 1G download and something significantly less than 1G for upload.
Comcast is the worst for this. Actual fiber companies are selling symmetric connections. Comcast still sells garbage like 1000gbps/30mbps. That is barely enough return bandwidth for traffic overhead.
I've seen 300/5 before which is way more crazy imo.
You forgot the data cap meaning while you can burst you can't exceed ~20 Mbit sustained (I'm not clear if the caps are typically bidirectional). Meanwhile the local fiber company doesn't say a thing even if I sustain upwards of 800 Mbit 24/7 for months on end.
I have Comcast/Xfinity here in the NE USA suburbs. It's not that bad, at least for me.
When downloading big files (browser, Steam, torrent) I regularly get sustained 30-50MB/sec which is pretty close to the download speed I pay for.
Do you have a data cap? If so, what sustained speed do you calculate it allows for?
Comcast quietly did away with their data caps some years ago.
nope. nearly went over within the last couple months and had to switch to leeching off the neighbors til it reset (which counts against neither of our caps at the cost of much lower speeds)
Hmm, I stand corrected I guess. Maybe it varies by market or plan.
Yes. Each state has regulations and they're forced to follow local laws.
Where I am (WA state) you can pay $10 or$15 or $20 to have no cap.
it depends on whether your address has another broadband provider
The Comcast plan I has from Oct 2024 to Oct 2026 had a 1.2TB data cap. It was $35 per month for something like 200Mbps down and 10Mbps up. I exceeded it a couple times and was charged $10 for 50GB.
Good grief. Comcast currently charges me $70/month for 125Mbps down. Thankfully I'm switching over to T-mobile fiber soon. (1 gig symmetric for $55/month.)
IIRC the one an acquaintance currently has is capped at approximately 6 Tbit (on which I based the earlier math). I'm not sure what the terms for exceeding it are.
Was just forced to upgrade to a 50% more expensive "modern" gigabit Comcast cable plan from my existing "legacy" gigabit plan after they retroactively added data caps (with additional charges for overage maxing out at $100, which I would max out every billing period).
The one perk is that they are actually gracing me with higher-than-advertised download bandwidth (I think like 1.2 or 1.3 gigabit), which I've never gotten out of them before. Previously it was consistently around 70% of the advertised speed because of "network conditions and capacity", yet miraculously upgrading to a higher speed would get you more bandwidth (up to 70% of the higher advertised speed!).
gig is short for "gig work" not "gig-abit"!
/s
The comparison charts for the services tend to be pretty dishonest, making ridiculous claims about what service you need to support basic vanilla levels of Internet activities. ("Want to send an email AND watch a Youtube video at the same time? You need our Ultra Super Fibernet Max Plus!")
Yeah, and "gaming" is always on the highest tier.
Exploiting once again the fact that people don't know the difference between throughput and latency...
And in most cases, the cheapest plan is enough for like 8 4K download streams at once, but uploading a small photo library to Google Drive takes hours.
The irony being that they're effectively wishing sites and services would become more inefficient so they can justify the amount of bandwidth they're selling.
On one hand, it's misleading. On the other, upstream and downstream capacities, quotas, and oversubscription ratios at different points in the network are what actually matter.
TMobile of all companies started offering fiber in my area. They ran fiber lines into the house. Real fiber too, I saw the install. 1000Mbps up/down. I hate Comcast & AT&T. TMobile for now can have all my money. So check your area if you are wanting to get one.
T-Mobile Fiber is almost always rebrands of local sub-carriers which T-Mobile either acquired or partner with - for example, in my area, they're the anchor tenant for Intrepid Fiber Networks. It's an interesting business model vs. a lot of the competitor models (either owned FTTP or fake-fiber like Comcast and old CenturyLink marketing)
AT&T and T-Mobile both installed fiber in my neighborhood this summer. AT&T started in the spring and still are not done. (Also their workers took out my cable internet with a shovel.)
T-Mobile had my street done in three weeks. They are offering twice the speed and half the price of my current plan through Comcast. I need to remember to call them tomrrow.
I am amazed you had two different fiber optic lines installed all the way to your home, in addition to coaxial cable. I only ever see fiber in new developments, and if there is buried coaxial cable in an old development, I have never seen it get fiber.
I remember reading about an (I think) european country where telco regulation meant that every home got two FTTH, and those were terminated in a central datacenter, meaning you could switch providers without changing equipment in your home. You would call them up, and they could switch it centrally. And you could have separate services on the separate fibers, for redundancy or comparison.
I'm struggling to search for the details now, but it sounded enlightened.
A relatively small company has been working on fiber in my little old post-industrial wasteland of a town in Ohio. (It's been a process for them -- their infrastructure is mostly underground.)
They finally got it into my neighborhood and I had it installed a couple of weeks ago. It's fiber all the way into the basement of the house where their ONT lives, right next to my router.
It's pretty great. Symmetric, gigabit (actually overprovisioned a bit at 1.2gbps or so). This opened the door to chase down some issues with queue management and NIC options for this OpenWRT build, but with that accomplished I can hammer it in both directions concurrently without latency spikes or SQM.
Previous to that, the only serious option here was Spectrum (in DOCSIS form since they're sleeping on their fiber rollouts). Spectrum worked quite well here for it was, but it was annoying having 500mbps of download and just 20mbps of upload. It's nice to get back to ISDN-esque symmetry like it's 1999 again.
You'd be amazed at how many small providers there are in the rural US that do decent fiber and wifi. In Ohio for example, off the top of my head: Paulding Putnam, TSC, Bascom. Some of them are 100 year old phone companies that pivoted to fiber, some are power companies, etc. And they have incredibly flat support structures eg after your ticket gets escalated it likely lands on the desk of the guy who programmed the OLT and the PE router. Sooo much nicer than Comcast and the other tier 1s.
Sadly their SEO budget is miniscule compared with those guys so they are often on page 2 of Google behind the wall of fake comparison sites.
Consumer protection via companies calling out their competitors for lies.
I wish there were more effective options in play, but this could be a positive outcome, up until they all agree to stop directly attacking each other.
Oddly, I'm kind of sympathetic with Xfinity here.
They now offer DOCSIS 4.0 1 gigabit and 2 gigabit fully symmetric connections over cable lines. Obviously it's not fiber, but it really does meet the average person's understanding of what "fast fiber optic internet" is in every way.
They also have 10Gbps
It's not quite fully symmetric -- in my area I get around 1800 down and 2350 up. Still better than 1200 down and 35 up. THIRTY-FIVE
`2350 up`
You have 2.3Gbps upload and 1.8Gbps download?
And yet, it’s still a lie.
If AT&T advertised their fiber as the fastest 5G around, that’d also be a lie.
Xfinity is saying their backhaul is fiber, not that your modem is fiber. In "next generation" areas, that seems to be true.
Everyone at that scale has some fiber somewhere, even if only between switches in their DC, but that misleads buyers by implying that their own connection will involve fiber.
Yeah I've started seeing Xfinity's billboards for this around town (a growing Houston area suburb), and it's odd to me advertising this as some new development, since I've had AT&T fiber for 4 1/2 years.
"Powered by fiber" started with Cox, then Charter bought them and adopted it, and then Xfinity latched on and followed along with the "well, HFC is technically fiber!" advertising game.
What I'd really like to know is what the hell is up with the constant begging to sign up for the (Spectrum) mobile service. I've seen free lines for a year being given out like candy (or even wilder, free Internet for business customers that buy 4 lines) and it feels like it's all just to juice the customer into either device payment plans on new equipment or just to look good for the next 4 quarters of mobile subscriber growth and sneak one past the investors.
It seems to me like everyone’s trying to bundle everything. Amazon prime wants you to bundle One Medical. Walmart+ bundles Paramount Plus or Peacock and you can now add Sam’s Club to the bundle. T-Mobile wants to bundle every streaming service you have.
Once all of your subscriptions are tangled into two or three big messes, it is extremely unattractive to think about switching any of them. “if I switch my cell service to Verizon, then I’ll have to go screw around trying to undo the combined billing for my Netflix account.” or “if we switch to the new fiber ISP, Spectrum will cancel our cell phones because you have to be a cable subscriber. Gee, I hope that they don’t screw something up and end up losing our phone numbers! Maybe we should just not switch.”
Verizon certainly tried their best to get me to not bundle.
I had Verizon phone service for years because my wife's job got her some kind of discount.
When I bought my home, I was excited to finally get off of Xfinity and onto Verizon FIOS. The old owner had Verizon FIOS. All the equipment was in place. All Verizon had to do was flip a switch.
Nope. They demanded a $200 deposit.
For what, I asked? I said I've been your customer for 5+ years, you obviously know where I live, and the equipment's already here. They couldn't tell me. I asked... well, when do I get my deposit back? They said when I terminate service. I said well, I bought a house and I plan to be here for around 30 years. Until I die, if things go well. So practically speaking, I never get my $200 back, or if I'm lucky maybe around the time Halley's Comet returns.
So, I regretfully had to tell them to fuck off. Did not exactly bring me any happiness to resign myself to Xfinity instead.
What a terrible business decision on their part. They've already lost $30,000 alone thanks to their insistence on getting that $200 deposit. Plus a couple of hundred bucks on all the snail mail spam they've sent me over the years telling me how great FIOS is...
For future reference, you don't need their help to activate anything if the equipment is already there. You can self-service you activation just by going to this URL: https://activate.verizon.com/
Source: I just did this myself last month
They do it because it makes customers stickier, I think.
All telcos offer huge discounts to sign up, but those discounts aren't sustainably profitable. So prices usually rise afterwards... And then customers move.
They are betting that if you sign up to cable + mobile, you will be less likely to switch for the competing offer, and pay the higher long term price.
I'm in Spectrum territory and laugh at the "Fiber-powered Internet" line whenever I see their ads. Technically, yes, it is fiber to the the nearest HFC node, but after that, good luck. There are supposedly a couple of locations where they'll give you actual fiber, but I've never seen one.
Anyway, I switched from cable to actual fiber a few years ago after a year of complaining to the HOA. I was getting massive packet loss and the upstream bandwidth would drop to single digit megabit speeds (they advertised 30.)
Anything greenfield, presumably. Also amusingly enough rural areas, where they took government money to roll out fibre in uneconomic footprints.
GFiber (formerly Google Fiber) is also often microwave. We have some of their radios on our apartment building roof.
I used to have a local ISP in SF which was microwave. It was excellent. Best ISP I’ve ever had. I loved that it had symmetrical uploads, in fact, my upload was often way higher than my download, I assume just because the downstream channel was more congested. But it was much faster than any other options in both directions.
Monkeybrains is a great ISP
Monkeybrains or Webpass? Our building has both, Webpass being bought by Google Fiber and now GFiber.
Its a matter of engineering. The problem isn't the technology, it's that microwave is really low hanging fruit that idiots can halfway engineer. Wireless is basically mud because of shitty sales guys throwing links up and then forcing customers to wear technical debt.
I think they bought webpass and rebranded it?
If you are talking about Seattle area, that's exactly what they did there.
To be fair, they did well by the original company, and in the region they officially refer to the service as "Google Fiber/Webpass" (or at least they did 3 years ago, before I left the area).
They definitely did that as well. In Austin, I had fiber-to-the-home and here in SF I had them as Microwave. The only FTTH I've had in SF is Sonic, though I've heard some people have AT&T Fiber.
Over a few weeks I watched an AT&T copper POTS box on the Delores street get hit by a truck, replaced, rewired with new copper, and the get an AT&T fiber decal slapped onto it.
I'd love to know if it's a real service anywhere in the city. Sonic is better but there coverage tends to be incomplete.
Sonic is good but they only serve areas with overhead power lines. They refuse to trench to lay fiber in places where utilities are buried.
I really wish the city would take control over getting fiber coverage everywhere. It's a little insane that in San Francisco, a city with a lot of very wealthy technology people, a large fraction of the city doesn't have fiber.
I heard a story of $famous_billionare_tech_exec calling up Sonic and asking them how much it would cost for him to pay them to lay fiber on his street (unfortunately don't remember what happened).
The city does take control of it. They’re the ones who blocked Sonic from microtrenching. I’m somewhat surprised as a SF resident that you believe that having the city government take control of something gets the thing done.
I have Sonic over in Alameda. $87 including taxes and state fees and all that for an uncapped 10Gbit connection with rock solid IPv6 and no prohibition against running home servers. I’ve never loved an ISP before.
Taking for granted that they're right about this being misleading...
> AT&T demands Comcast give AT&T profits it made from advertising cable as fiber.
...is that really how it works? Your competitors get your profits? Are there no competitors beside AT&T?
they don't even offer fiber here, I've asked them multiple times
they should be focusing on that so that they can credibly claim they are actually competition
this strikes me as more similar to patent trolling
Common sense says anything other than “FTTH” is not really fiber. Having some fiber in the network backbone (which is basically everything in 2026) doesn’t count as “fiber.”
Fiber is a pure and fully symmetrical signal in just your home. Coax is basically just RF over a wire and highly susceptible to all sorts of issues. That includes anyone in your neighborhood doing any of a long list of things including something as simple as having a cable not plugged into anything… which causes chaos on RF networks.
Coming from Comcast though, I suppose we shouldn’t be surprised at this nonsense.
I mean Comcast is "fibre powered" from the CMTS onwards.
And DOCSIS4.0 can offer higher speeds than AT&Ts older GPON FTTH.
But regardless it is extremely odd Comcast is spending so much to do a DOCSIS4.0 upgrade, given the costs between that and eg XGSPON are not huge - both require a lot of new equipment and fibre laid.
I am unaware of anyone but Comcast that is adopting DOCSIS4. Afiak all European cable companies are moving to XGS-PON.
I'm on a 2Gbps/2Gbps (but more like 2.5/2.5) DOCSIS4.0 plan in Seattle and as much as I hate to say it, it's been great.
But like, why would they go all the way to XGS-PON when they can use their existing HFC access network, maybe upgrade that to DAA/RPHY, combined with existing subscriber outside plant, and deliver an incremental improvement? As much as I'd love 10Gbps+ service, 2Gbps is already bananas, and there's nothing stopping them from replacing the last mile with glass eventually, either.
Well firstly, DOCSIS is becoming an increasingly niche technology, and niche technology in telecoms means expensive. There are probably 10,000x more (XGS)G-PON CPEs being manufactured than DOCSIS4.0 ones. I assume similar scale for PON headend equipment.
Secondly, PON basically has no powered equipment outside the 'exchange', which can serve 30k+ customers. DOCSIS requires loads of powered equipment, amplifiers, CMTS etc. This then costs money to power (and in high temps, cool) and more importantly breaks down more often. DOCSIS4.0 requires a lot of upgrades to the 'last mile' part so most telcos have decided to just go the whole way and replace with PON instead of doing all that work and getting none of the operational cost savings.
The issue is the faster you push DOCSIS the more it shows up any problems in your last mile setup.
You said it right there - we’re talking about Comcast here, so obviously if they could save even a nickel by using a technology that’s worse for the customer, they’ll choose that every time. It’s not like they have any competition to worry about! I’m aware AT&T has actual fiber in a few spots, but it’s so sparse compared to the whole footprint that Comcast DGAF if everyone with someone else’s fiber available drops them.
Oh that’s funny, I had the same gripe with Comcast - they kept saying they’d deliver fiber to the house, they’d install it, then it’d turn out to be coax/cable.
My roommates and I had them out to install, then canceled and refunded, like three times over the course of our ten years of living together. Each time, comcast and the installers lied about the service they were selling us.
> “Comcast should be required to restore to AT&T any and all profits earned as a result of its false and misleading advertising or provide AT&T with any other restitutionary relief the Court deems appropriate,” the lawsuit said. The lawsuit asked for a permanent injunction “requiring Comcast to cease describing its hybrid fiber-coaxial service as ‘Fiber-Powered.’”
The people Comcast is swindling with their false claims are their own customers, not AT&T. In what universe should this money be refunded to AT&T? It was never theirs! They are not entitled to other people's money!
If I sell something and someone wins customers away from me by means of false advertising and it's reasonably clear those customers would otherwise have patronized me then I have suffered proportional damages.
There are two basic attitudes to customers: people vs livestock.
In the former view customers are actual humans, your equals, who have rights and are as deserving of good treatment as you are.
In the latter, customers are your property. Once you have penned them in, you should be able to milk them as you please. They have no rights, and any noise they make to the contrary is so much mooing. Anybody milking customers that are rightfully yours isn't stealing from them. They're stealing from you.
AT&T also marketed their 4G network as "5GE" which was flagrant false advertising. I don't think corporate really cares, they just want to harm the other corporation. This is just the status quo of telecommunications and tech in America. It's all a scam and marketing, and if you complain, then you're fired.
I got frustrated with my spectrum docsis and decided to look for fiber providers in the area (One Wilshire is two blocks away, but no fiber around in residential buildings). Found Earthlink, went through hell trying to sign up with their voice llm bot, and then final ToS is something like this "just so you know, while plan called 'a gig', you probably going to get 400/20 at most".
Reminded me of a Spectrum guy crimping coaxial cable in front of and me telling me its fiber.
Retention guy tried to convince me that Spectrum was “mostly fiber”. Like yeah I’m sure there’s fiber in your network, let me know when it’s touching my house and I’ll switch back.
CenturyLink carpetbombed my neighborhood with comments on how we might have seen their vans and we have fiber.
I didn’t think so. Checked online, not within 50 miles. Called because why not, leaflet, door to door. Nope.
Then “why do you need gigabit? Perhaps you’re paying for sport you don’t need?” (They only offered 24mbps).
No dude, sorry, not paying ten buck less for fifty times less speed (and I work from home in an industry that uses a good amount of bandwidth, my partner also works from home part time, stepdaughter loves her 4K.
Yes, still a lot of headroom, including game and media download. But hah “you probably couldn’t tell the difference most of the time”?
Kinda rich coming from AT&T, the people who brought you "5Ge"
lol. The only company lazier than Comcast at building FTTP[1] is throwing stones at them. Hilarious! AT&T barely showed up with fiber outside of big buildings when I lived in SF, topping out with 20Mb UVerse as recently as 2017. Now, I live in another area in their footprint and they just aren’t even playing. If you put my address in, in a high-priced suburb, they suggest cellular internet. I’d still be happy to see any big telecom ISP lose a lawsuit like this, because they’re all scum.
[1] edit: I should’ve said “building out infrastructure” since Comcast to be fair doesn’t build any FTTP to speak of, whereas AT&T builds a tiny bit. But if the question is “percentage of your footprint that can access a speed of 1Gbps over the infrastructure you’ve laid to their house” Comcast wins by a (last) mile.
I was still thinking about this, and went looking for more - the FCC's broadband maps[0] claims that AT&T FTTP covers ~18% of units. So, definitely nowhere near universal, but I guess I'd count that as more than "a tiny bit".
[0] https://broadbandmap.fcc.gov/provider-detail/fixed?version=j...
For what it’s worth, my mid-sized city in the Midwest has quite a bit of AT&T FTTP and they are expanding at a reasonable pace. I would estimate they cover 80% of the neighborhoods around me (3 years ago, they covered 0%). This is all area previously only serviced by Spectrum coax (asymmetrical DOCSIS).
When I moved into my current address, the property manager told me I had two options for my ISP: Spectrum or AT&T. Of course as soon as I select AT&T I get a call from one of their sales people telling me "no lol, we aren't actually available there"
So once again, stuck with Spectrum.
No love for Comcast here, but I'd be a lot more sympathetic to AT&T's argument if they were actually willing to offer their fiber service to me.
Do USAians still believe in free market?
Funny enough, I got an ad in the mail from AT&T and saw the strange wording and used Claude to dig into it.
Immediately I was like, "Ohhh. They're full of shit. Got it."
I use AI to disambiguate all sorts of marketing nonsense these days. It's amazing.
PoE, but over fiber. That would be fiber powered.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Power-over-fiber
There's not really consumer-available stuff, but there is expensive purpose built stuff you can buy for thousands of dollars to send tiny amounts of power.
That would also be the most terrifyingly dangerous development in power delivery to ever occur.
Bonus, you can plug it into a laser cutter too I guess ?
I worked at Trumpf for a few months, we would shove 10000 watts down a fiber for industrial laser cutters.
Att took my $50 deposit, cancelled install day of.
Week of asking for a new date went by without receiving one.
Cancelled service order.
Att only sounds better in their PR releases.
Spectrum does this as well. "Fiber" sounds bettet then "Same Shit" I suppose
Cable in my country had the advantage that it was already in every home- it was installed all the way back in the 80s to replace the infamous antennas.
But no matter what you do it is ancient tech that can't beat fiber so dig dig dig!
I was wondering how Comcast was going to fulfill their mailer ad to serve fiber to my home while there has been no digging in the ground.
well, it IS fiber-powered (fibers of copper wire)
Pot calling the kettle black.
"Fiber-powered" reminds me of when you see an inverter advertised as "modified sine wave." Or something in the dairy case at the grocery store labeled "cheese food product."
Both of these companies are doing the same thing. Yes, obviously Comcast is using the word "fiber" to try to piggy-back on the layman's shallow understanding of that word as "fancy Internet thing".
But so is AT&T. The practical limits of optical and DOCSIS are basically equivalent to a home user, but AT&T pitches their product as "fiber" to dazzle the uneducated customer.
In an ideal world, they'd compete just on latency, throughput, and reliability.
But AT&T actually runs fiber so I'm not following you here. I have AT&T and it's a real fiber optic cable they ran from the pole into my house. What are you getting at? Meanwhile, Comcast does, in fact, claim they are fiber even though they run coax cable.
I have 'cable', but it's actually fiber to my house and there is a power injector in my closet that runs power over the 30' of coax I have to run a coax to fiber converter of some kind. This isn't Comcast, but I suspect lots of new builds have odd things like this. Most people would have no clue what's running to the side of their house.
That's not particularly odd - FTTH with MoCA (ie coax) from the ONT to the vendor supplied router was standard at one point. However I believe most ISPs that offer fiber have moved to an ONT that integrates the router at this point due to throughput requirements as many of them now offer routine home service in excess of 5 Gbit.
Meanwhile comcast largely does not do FTTH, at least where I'm at. (They do have fiber to a box a few blocks down the street in many neighborhoods here though.)
In my area Comcast is only doing fiber for new multi-family construction.
Brand new construction is still getting regular coax even if the new neighborhood is getting its own fiber run and node.
I do not understand why; seems like anything we're going to do to get more bandwidth out of shared coax is going to be expensive? Seems like we have a lot more room in the optical space?
Comcast has tons of fiber just like their competitors. They're using "Hybrid Fiber Coax" plant, where only the last 100m or so is coax. Walk around the neighborhood and you'll see the fiber (orange sleeves on the cable and slack coils).
> But AT&T actually runs fiber so I'm not following you here.
Certainly, at&t has been running fiber for the better part of a century.
That said, they were selling u-verse DSL as 'fiber' back when I was in their territory; they did bring fttp to my premesis eventually, but only after Google announced they were building out (Google didn't, of course).
The nutritional values of potatoes and rice are basically equivalent to the average eater. Would it be okay if a "sushi" restaurant stuffed yours with mashed potato instead of rice?
The problem is that Comcast is lying. They are marketing one product (fiber) and delivering another (DOCSIS). That's fraud.
This lawsuit would not exist if Comcast had stuck to a marketing term such as "fiber-like speeds". But they got too greedy, and ended up misleading the consumer.
>The nutritional values of potatoes and rice are basically equivalent to the average eater.
But they're not. Potatoes are far more nutritious than rice
So that should make the disgusting surprise potato sushi a great deal for the fine diner, right?